My take.
AL MVP
1. Josh Hamilton
2. Miguel Cabrera
3. Mike Trout
(Actually I think Cabrera should be MVP, but I doubt the Tigers will make the playoffs, and that counts)
NL MVP
1. Buster Posey
2. Ryan Braun
3. Andrew McClutchen
AL Cy Young
1. David Price
2. Chris Sale
3. Fernando Rodney
NL Cy Young
1. Gio González
2. R.A. Dickey
3. Johnny Cueto
@fbaezer,
Quote:(Actually I think Cabrera should be MVP, but I doubt the Tigers will make the playoffs, and that counts)
if he wins the triple crown (currently leads in avg + rbi, 1 back in homers), how can they
not name him MVP?
@Region Philbis,
You're right, Region.
How can they not?
They should, regardless of the triple crown.
I still think they prefer Josh.
@fbaezer,
winning the triple crown won't be easy, however -- there is an excellent battle for the AL HR title a-brewin'...
@Region Philbis,
Winning the Triple Crown has not guaranteed the MVP award previously. The most famous case is that of the great Ted Williams, who won the Triple Crown TWICE and finished 2nd in the voting both times.
You know, Region, those NYC press-boys-Babe Ruth suckers.
Is there a dirtier name in baseball today than Buster Posey?
@patiodog,
nope, not since we saw the likes of Dick Pole, Paul Assenmacher and Rusty Kuntz.
good to see you back, 'dawg...
@fbaezer,
it's been so long (45 years) since yaz did it -- maybe the novelty of it would put him over the top?
not only is the homer title up for grabs, but now mauer has inched past trout in batting average...
congrats to miggy on
winning the triple crown.
texas staggered into the playoffs, losing the AL west to oakland in grand fashion in game #162.
meanwhile, the tigers won the AL central.
me thinks giving cabrera the MVP over hamilton is a no-brainer...
@Region Philbis,
Yeah, a complicated man with a classic performance.
@Region Philbis,
I gotta agree with Region and re-do my prediction. Hamilton's error helped, too.
So... Miguel Cabrera for AL MVP
...And for President of Venezuela. His alcohol problems notwithstanding, he's a much smarter choice than either Chavez or Capriles.
@fbaezer,
I enjoyed watching him produce every day.
he gets my vote for certain...
now who's the NL guy?
@Rockhead,
still think braun, posey a close second...
On an aside, while it is obvious Mike Trout should have won the ROY for the American League, I disagree with the NL choice, Bryan Harper.
I think Wilin Rosario was REALLY overlooked because he had no media hype before his MLB debut.
See the numbers:
Harper: .270, 22 home runs, 59 RBI
Rosario: .270, 28 HR, 71 RBI
AND Rosario is a catcher.
Probably Harper will have a greater career than Rosario, but the Colorado catcher had a better rookie season.
@Region Philbis,
My batting average on this stuff is still very high.