Valid Reasons for Allowing Gays to Marry
Thank you for the thoughts and your poem,
Piffka.
I'm not replying to offend you,
stuh505, but it seems that many people don't understand what allowing gays to marry entails, nor do they understand some of the history of marriage.
Marriage has not always been about love, nor has it been solely related to spirituality. For example, in ancient Rome a man wasn't considered a citizen until he was married. Even today many people, in countries other than the US, are still under the control of their parents UNTIL they marry. So you can safely assume that some of those people marry to get out of their parents homes and out from under their control. Also, what many people don't know, the Catholic Church had nothing to do with marriage during it's first 1000 years - marriage wasn't yet considered an official Catholic sacrament, and weddings weren't performed in churches.
And more recently, marriage was not allowed to "people of color", nor were people allowed to marry someone of the "wrong" race. Nor during the history of marriage were women given the same rights....there was a time when once a woman married, she was considered her husband's personal property! Many marriages were due to dynastic (promising your daughter to someone because of you or your family's social status) or property arrangements. Any real estate/property that a woman owned automatically became her husband's; and women lost their rights to sign contracts or to sue anyone.
Marriage isn't the same as it always has been throughout history, as many people mistakenly assume. It's changed considerably!
Now onto what allowing gays to marry is all about. For some it IS about having their love recognized publicly. But, also for others, it entails MANY privileges, benefits, and responsibilities that heterosexuals probably don't think twice about receiving AUTOMATICALLY upon marrying. Here are just a few of them:
Death - One partner dies, the other is not entitled to bereavement leave, wrongful death claims, Social Security, or inheiriting a shared home, any assets or personal items of their deceased partner.
Family Leave - Laws and polices do not usually cover unmarried couples that may need to leave work to care for a sick partner or their children.
Health - Unmarried partners are not considered next of kin, therefore hospital visitations are not allowed. This, for the one person whom loves you the most! Partners aren't even allowed to make emergency medical decisions. Plus, most health plans don't cover unmarried partners or their children, and if there are ways to cover partners and their children, there are huge taxes on that coverage. They're also not eligible for Medicare or Medicaid.
Housing - Unmarried couples can easily be denied if in need of public housing.
Immigration - Partners can be deported if marriage isn't possible.
Inheritance - Partners can't automatically inherit property if their loved one dies without a will. And they don't get legal protection for inheritance rights.
Insurance - Unmarried couples can't always sign up for joint insurance (home, auto, health - you name it) A majority of employers don't cover domestic partners or their children.
Parenting - Joint parenting, adoption, foster care or visitation is denied to unmarried couples.
Court - Unmarried couples may be forced to testify against each other in court. (Can you imagine...?)
Real Estate - They can't buy property together under the special rules that married couples can, plus they aren't entitled to all the privileges of owning that property together AS a married couple, including things that can happen should one partner die.
Retirement - Social Security and Medicare are denied to gay partners. IRAs and other retirement account withdrawals and protective tax treatments are denied to partners.
Taxes - Unmarried couples can't file joint tax returns and do not receive any special tax benefits given to married couples. Therefore they are forced to file under a higher single-person rate. Plus they're denied the right to transfer property to each other and other special arrangements without severe tax consequences.
These are just to name a few. Gay couples cannot visit a lawyer and receive all/any these rights without paying extremely large amounts of money. Even then, the rights automatically given with marriage of heterosexuals cannot be replicated for homosexual couples by paying a lawyer.
And again to speak to your comment on the spirituality of marriage...here are a few more thoughts for you...
The founding fathers of this country knew that mixing the church and state was not that right thing to do. That is why the vehemenently opposed it...they knew that it caused many problems back in Europe.
The right to marry in this country is first and foremost a legal one. It never matters if you marry in a church, but it DOES matter if you don't sign the marriage license. You're not married if that's not taken care of, whether you were married in a church by a pastor or priest.
The Catholic Church has never condoned divorce, and it believes that marriage is a "union for life", however when was the last time you heard a Catholic leader screaming at the government NOT to issue marriage licenses to divorced people...?
Also, what's there to be said about the Mormon settlers who moved in the early 1900's to Mexico to avoid the polygamy laws of the US? (I'm assuming it's safe to bet that polygamy isn't covered in your idea of marriage.)
There are so many different religions in the US alone. It would
never be fair to impose one or two upon the entire country. I note again....our founding fathers knew what the heck they were doing!
There are so many denominations who have spoken out FOR marriage equality. I could go on forever about this, but I will stop here. If you'd like to discuss this more, please let me know.
And please understand I'm not trying to upset you, I only wish to educate people who don't understand what allowing gays to marry REALLY means...
Thanks.
G