@MonaLeeza,
MonaLeeza wrote:
I don't believe that honesty is necessarily the best policy in 100% of situations. Every relationship is unique. My husband and I spend long periods apart from each other and it is an unspoken rule that we don't ask each other awkward questions - I think that has been a strength in our relationship and has seen us through some rough spots. I don't believe that he is cheating at the moment and I know I'm not. I'm not interested in what he might have done in the past and I'd be horrified if he ever felt the need to tell me.
Another story: Once upon a time in a small country town my grandfather was screwing the woman who would become his second wife . Meanwhile his first wife, my grandmother was dying of cancer. She was the only one in the town including my mother (still at school then) who didn't know what was going on. The minister of her church felt that she had a right to know and so took it upon himself to tell her - so she spent her final months in emotional as well as physical pain. Not everything needs to be said just because it is the truth.
I agree. However, everyone telling him to 'just hide it' will only perpetuate his already skewed idea that so long as he can keep everything hidden he can get away with it.
And as I said, I'm speaking from my own personal experience. I'm not so full of myself as to believe that my experience can apply to everyone, but I'd be remiss to point it out to a man who is going through something very similar to what I did.
Everyone has one or two or twelve sob stories they can pull out to justify keeping it a secret. None of which appear to directly relate to the situation that the original poster has provided other than they're tear jerker scenarios meant to get a point across.
I get that, and again I accept that my view will not be the popular view
nor will it be applicable to all cases. It might be completely wrong for him as thus far he's shown no signs of having any kind of moral compass at all, and the main drive for me confessing to my wife was the fact that the guilt I was feeling was tainting my interactions with her. To clear that air I felt it was best for me to confess and rebuild.
If he finds himself in a similar situation, he can choose to accept my advice. If not, he can choose to hide it and hope she never finds out down the road.
The one thing that no one has commented on yet is how much more damaging the situation will be when/if his wife discovers what's happened AFTER he's left his girlfriend, spent years getting to love his wife fully, developed a long lasting relationship with her, spent all the time and hours into it.
So you go down the long, windy road of working on, improving, flourishing your marriage and then that ticking time bomb drops and it's all for naught.
Anyway. I'll stop beating a dead horse now.