@panzade,
Quote:Pretty good summation of your distaste for this project, firefly.
Actually, I have no distaste for the idea of a community center/mosque. It seems like a rather good idea.
What seems very clear to me is that the backers of this project did not do enough groundwork/homework before starting to move ahead with it. This failure is at least partially responsible for the substantial, and somewhat ugly, opposition that has developed.
The people behind this project, Rauf and Khan, live in NYC and have been there for decades. They know that the 9/11 families have often expressed opposition to almost any proposal regarding Ground Zero. They know that, since 9/11, other Muslims have experienced various kinds of difficulties with various businesses and projects in the City. And they know that Iman Abdul Rauf has long been a somewhat controversial figure because he tends to equivocate on his feelings about terrorist groups like Hamas.
They should have done more community outreach before moving ahead with their project. They should have made an attempt to meet with various community groups, and the 9/11 families, to try to resolve problems and objections, before the firestorm was allowed to develop. Even Daisy Khan now admits that this failure was a mistake on their part. They didn't even meet with other Muslim organizations in the City who have deal with anti-Muslim sentiment since 9/11 and are more experienced in successfully resolving it.
So, the blunders made by the backers of this project, and their failure to try to smooth the waters beforehand, contributed to fomenting the opposition they are now dealing with. Had they deal with some of the issues beforehand, the more legitimate issues, they would have had a more united force behind them to help stifle the ugly voices of the outright bigots and the right wing political agitators. By the time they realized their error, and belatedly hired a P.R. firm in May, the damage was already done and it was too extensive to be contained.
At this point, I do think they have to reconsider and try to re-locate their project. Not only is the opposition too overwhelming (68% of NYers are now against the community center/mosque being built near Ground Zero), but too much vitriolic anti-Islam feeling is being generated, and it is counterproductive to their own stated aims. I think they were wrong not to have at least met with Gov. Paterson to discuss the possibility of the state helping them to find an alternative location. Now it does look like they are plain insensitive to the issue of whether their project offends other residents of NYC.
I think the people behind this project are backing themselves into a dangerous corner if they do not re-locate. The prejudice toward Muslims, all Muslims, is gaining a frightening momentum which may not dissipate very quickly at all, and this would be a terrible setback for intergroup relations in the City and the country. Unfortunately, the bigots can make a great deal of noise, and they can drown out the voices of reason because they are playing on people's fears about their own security, and, the media attention quickly spreads their message on a national level.
At this point, the opposition to this project is so strong, and includes so many different issues, and groups, and individuals, with differing kinds of objections, I think it is impossible to put the genie back into the bottle so this project could move ahead, in its current location, without creating lasting feelings of bitterness, and even hatred, in the hearts of most NYers. To allow that to happen, would be foolhardy at best.
For those reasons, I do feel they should seek an alternate site for this project. And, when they find it, they should build an even larger community center/mosque than the one they are now considering.