@OmSigDAVID,
I shall explain.
There have been incidents in the past where A2Kers (and, before that, Abuzzers -- this has gone on for over a decade) had their sympathies played upon. This was due to hoaxes. People pretending to be beaten wives, to be caring for dying parents or children, or suicidal or the like. One of the signs is to see these kind of scenarios constantly paraded in front of the site. E. g. the perpetrator finds a way to keep interest up. Primes the pump, so to speak.
Just when interest is dying down, something else happens, or some other little nugget of information is released. The poster is suddenly pregnant! Or the boyfriend is fresh out of jail! Or the long-lost father just returned! Or the doctors are doing all they can but it's too late! Etc. etc. etc.
Having the original poster be attacked by some sort of troll, particularly a troll who seems to know too much insider information, is another way to prime the pump.
As a result, A2Kers have gotten somewhat skeptical. It can be hard to give your heart again, after it's been trampled on several times over and again. It is easy to be jaded. And, sadly, being jaded is often the rightest response.
It does not mean that there aren't perfectly legitimate suffering people out there. There is, for real, far more suffering out there than any of us can or could bear, if we really knew about all of it. But we who have been burned certainly do not wish to have falsified suffering thrust upon us. Enough already! We'd rather save our sympathies for those who truly need them.
But it's hard to know just who those people are.
Hence, people are skeptical, or they may become skeptical, or they may, at times, be sympathetic and skeptical all at the same time, or in stages, or alternate. These kinds or responses are all perfectly normal. They are our responses to having been burned before. None of us wishes to be burned again. But, at the same time, we are generally genuinely compassionate people. We do very much wish to believe.
So questioning is going to come up, and come up repeatedly. And it's not intended to be an insult to anyone and
should not be taken as such.
And another thing.
There are those of us who have been burned so repeatedly that we don't put ourselves out there
at all. Kind, compassionate folks who absent themselves from topics where they might normally pour on the sympathy -- this is because they are either skeptical from the get-go, or they are afraid they will become skeptical or hurt. Or, of course, they might not see the topic at all. That happens, too.
Anyway, just to bring this all to a conclusion: I think that being skeptical and having questions is normal. I think that wondering whether someone is legitimate, even after they seem to be proven, is completely normal. And, I think that showing sympathy is also normal. Me? My philosophy is to show sympathy (because I really do care), but also to reserve my heart. I don't wish the worst on anyone, and it's an odd position to be in -- to be wishing that someone has had harm befall them as that legitimizes them. But I also look at a larger audience. Even if the one, particular person is not legit, someone out there might be. My sympathy, and my words, are for that legitimately suffering person, whether they are in front of me now, or will join A2K in a week or a month, or they are lurking, or they follow along and don't show themselves at all.
I hope this helps.