@ehBeth,
ehBeth wrote:
OmSigDAVID wrote:She is a member of an ethnic group
that has treated me somewhat harshly,
when I offer consolation of this nature.
you may believe you are offering consolation.
Offending someone's religious beliefs may have had the opposite effect.
I never did so
overtly.
In the most dramatic event of expressed resentment
(hereinabove set forth) she had lamented that the
worst pain
that she suffered (in the past and present) was loss of her son in the distant past.
I have
almost never brought up the subject of religion
in addressing people. Considerable experiences with making
efforts to console the newly bereaved have led me to believe
that a hi proportion of members of that ethnic group are emotionally
invested in ceasing to exist when the human body becomes
dysfunctional. Some of them have said that explicitly.
Obviously, everyone has a right to desire whatever he chooses
to desire. I got the vague impression of quiet
fear from them,
but I have no idea what thay fear.
People who have returned from "death" have said that thay liked
it, if thay remembered it -- most of the time. There were some
reports of bad experiences from suicides and from atheists.
(The latter changed their minds and yelled for help.)
Something that has
never happened,
is that we have
never had any reports of anyone having trouble
because of membership in any particular religion.
The closest to that which I can remember reading
was the temporary "death" from a heart attack
of a "fire and brimstone" Protestant preacher,
who had a life review experience, who saw
himself threatening his congregation, as usual,
including a ten year old boy, whom he recognized,
who was taking him seriously -- quaking in his boots.
When he returned from "death" he said:
"I was surprized that God was not interested in my theology."
He said that he calmed down and relaxed in the practice of his profession.
David