@aidan,
Quote:Man rose to the top of the food chain
by the adroit use of logic. We shoud cultivate logic,
not adhere to and promote liberal deviations from logic,
including spoken expression.
aidan wrote:
Quote:Well here's some logic for you - if it's more than sixty seconds -
they'll start using the word 'minute' - if it's more than fourteen minutes -
they'll break it down into fractions of hours -
Not
necessarily.
aidan wrote:
Quote:if it's more than twenty-three hours they'll describe it in days -
if it's more than six days they'll start using the word 'week' - and on into months and years, etc...
Experience has disproven your allegations,
tho what u allege might happen on
some occasions.
Very commonly time is set forth in different units e.g. 90 minutes,
45 days, 60 days, or any accurate measurements.
aidan wrote:
Quote:When I say, 'It happened so fast - literally within seconds'....
the people around me who are thinking logically should be able to
ascertain that I mean in less than a minute- (or really fast).
U appear to be confusing frequent usage with logic,
which is akin to competent mathematical analysis.
If something happened "within seconds" that might be
within millions of seconds. U have failed to give
anything approximating an accurate measure of time.
Such representations can be deceptive.
Quote:Logically, the first dinosaur was hatched within minutes ago
and within seconds ago; its just that many billions of seconds are involved.
It is logical to say the next century will begin within minutes,
in that it surely WILL, allowing enuf minutes.
aidan wrote:
Quote:I don't find that a logical use of the words we have to express time at all.
And thinking that anyone else would - is illogical.
It appears that u r distorting the concept of logic,
which is a purely mathematical concept, rendered in prose.
That will not work.
If u engage a workman to do a job that he promises
to complete "within hours" and he completes a few years later,
he can accurately reduce those years to hours.
It is ez math.
It will only take
A FEW seconds.
People shoud say what thay mean
and mean what thay say.
Your post defends sloppy conceptualizing.
David