McTag wrote:Hooray, chichan's back!
Don't agree with your first para. You seem to have redefined "ungrammatical" in an unhelpful and perverse way.
If one form (the written form, say) is grammatical and the other is different, is it not more useful to describe it as ungrammatical but permissible in the circumstances?
Thanks for the warm reception.
Actually, McTag, I've described it as it is in reality. Since the foundation of all languages resides in the spoken form, it's not at all helpful to force this apples versus oranges comparison. It has long led to folks expressing things about language that simply aren't true.
Each realm of language has its own set of rules. What aspect of writing shall we define all language by; academic writing, fiction, newspaper and magazine or some other form?
Just as the rules for these registers differ, so do the rules for speaking.