@snood,
For the record: I
can't say with absolute certainty that Noonan voted for Obama because to my knowledge she has never admitted to it.
I can say with certainty that she was smitten with the young Senator from Illinois in 2008 as evidenced by the following column, only one of her frequent paeans, in the press or on TV, during that time:
http://www.peggynoonan.com/article.php?article=440
I can also say with certainty that Ms Noonan repeatedly bashed George W Bush, John McCain and Sarah Palin and is true to form now with Mitt Romney.
What's more, I can say with certainty that she has assiduously cultivated a persona of the "intellectual, reasonable and cultured conservative" that Liberals will
respect (David Brook is her male counterpart) because she essentially agrees with them and can be used in a "See? Even conservative Peggy Noonan/David Brooks thinks that (fill in the blank) is a clod!" argument.
The
allegation that Peggy Noonan voted for Obama is common short-hand on the right for calling her out as a phony. It has the added benefit of very probably being correct.
Did I make the statement to impugn her
credibility as a conservative?
Absolutely.
When Politico asked Chris Wallace if
conservative pundits (like Noonan and Brooks) have any influence on actual conservatives, Wallace replied:
"Some of the people you've mentioned, like Peggy Noonan, sometimes they're New York City's idea of conservatives"
That was the polite Mr. Wallace saying what virtually all conservatives believe: She's such a phony, she even voted for Obama.
Who will be surprised if snood tells us that Peggy Noonan is the one conservative he has always admired? And if I demand that he proves it?
I could just as easily and just as self-servingly offer up as defacto truth the raking across coals of Barack Obama by
liberals like Pat Cadell and Douglas Schoen, but for what purpose? And if snood declared that they both voted for McCain in 2008, I assure you that I wouldn't demand that he offer us proof or be revealed as a
bullshit liar (as a matter of fact, he's long ago accomplished that feat).
For the record: This is a forum for discussion and opinion and these selective demands for proof positive of opinions is overdone. If I ignore one of these demands, I suppose it may appear that I am ducking a righteous challenge, but I can live with that.
I am also of the thinking that if someone states something in this forum that another member believes to be nonsense it is up to that member to prove it is blather, not simply make a haughty demand for
proof.
Undoubtedly those who think poorly of me will find much in this reply to criticize and confirm their poor thinking. So be it.
Why snood has gotten his panties in a wad about my assertion that Peggy Noonan voted for Obama is curious. You would think that he believes I have accused her of molesting a child. Now I may think there is a rough equivalence between the two acts, but I doubt snood does.
I'm sure Ms Noonan would appreciate snood defending her conservative bonafides, but does anyone really believe it's her honor that he cares about?
For the record: Snood really doesn't care for me...but that should be clear to all.
For the record: I don't care for or about snood, the only person in this forum, including to my recollection JTT, to call me a racist.