@CalamityJane,
CalamityJane wrote:
Cycloptichorn wrote:We invaded Afghansitan b/c the sons-of-bitches who ran the place were defending terrorists who attacked us; when we asked them to turn the guys over for justice, they very famously and loudly told us to **** off. So we went in and destroyed their asses, an act which we had the perfect right to do, and if some other country attacks us in the same fashion, we'll do it again. The only problem is that we didn't leave immediately afterward, but Bush had some sort of Crusade in his mind (the original plan was to take out Pakistan, Iran and Syria as well, and if things hadn't gone south in Iraq, they would have tried to do it). Don't you forget that their leadership invited us to attack them through both their actions and their words.
Bin Laden escaped to Pakistan after 9/11 - even the NYTimes reported about it then. Bush still invaded Afghanistan hoping to emerge as the big warrior. Remember his saying that "we'll go in there and out in 3 months".
To put it simply: Bullshit. You don't know what you are talking about.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tora_Bora
http://news.antiwar.com/2011/04/26/leaked-docs-osama-didnt-flee-to-pakistan-after-all/
We had no solid information as to where he had gone after Tora Bora. I could care less what the NYT reported. Not only that, but the battle of Tora Bora took place from December 12-15, 2001 - over two months after the date of our invasion.
I'll say it again - you are repeating falsehoods as if you have studied this issue when it's clear you haven't. Can you come back with even an iota of proof to support your contention? Or are you too busy accusing people of being 'bullies' to do so?
Quote:Nothing, absolutely nothing justified the war on Afghanistan or Iraq for that matter, since we later found out that the weapon of mass destruction were a hoax. Oh well, then we got rid of Saddam Hussein, that should justify invading Iraq, shouldn't it?
I agree with you about Iraq. There was no justification for that war. But to say the same about Afghanistan is foolish, extremely so. What there was - and is - no justification for is the decade-long occupation, the very thing YOU want to continue. But with no goals and no means of achieving them, you just want us to 'fix things.' That's cheerleading, a hope, not a plan.
Quote:You know, as a German I fully acknowledge the utter atrocities of WWII, and Germany is making certain that history never repeats itself. However, in comparison, the United States a) never acknowledges its wrongdoings
Obama has acknowledged several mistakes that we've made.
Quote:b) never learns from mistakes and
I also don't believe this is anything more than an assertion.
Quote: c) disregards any and every international laws that were set at the Geneva convention and/or Den Hague.
This is also absolute bullshit. You don't seem to realize that the US could - at any moment we chose - absolutely and completely destroy any country on the planet. We could destroy your country. We have the power to kill every one of your citizens with our military and nuclear arsenal. We have the ability to do that to any country on the planet. I'm not saying this as a threat, or as some sort of cowboy-ism on my part- these are plain facts. When you have over 3,000 nuclear weapons and the largest and most modern military in the world, these are your capabilities.
The truth is that we could have killed every single person in Afghanistan and occupied the country as OUR territory if we had wanted to. But we didn't and wouldn't do something like that, not just because it's the wrong thing to do, but because we respect international laws that say things like that just shouldn't be done anymore. Why wouldn't we respect them? If it wasn't for the US those laws
never would have been written. Your country certainly wouldn't have done it - if we didn't force you to participate after subduing your ultimate aggression 70 years ago. That's really not all that long ago, you know that?
For any German to be making such statements about America, well. I don't really have to go any further, do I?
Quote:Whatever the U.S. administration does, it's justified somehow by someone and all is well. Read "Confessions of an economic Hitman" - very insightful.
This is another false assertion. Not everything we do is justified or justifiable, and all is not well. We have and will in the future do things that deserve to be condemned. Some of us in this country have been working hard for a long time to get our own leaders held to a higher standard. But you're too busy lumping everyone in the same pot, and calling us 'cowboy bullies' to realize that.
I will wait for you to detail exactly what the plan is to 'fix things' in Afghanistan. Maybe then I'll take your pronouncements that we shouldn't leave more seriously.
Cycloptichorn