@hamburgboy,
hamburgboy wrote:
foxfire wrote :
Quote: Anecdotal evidence is always useful to illustrate a point. It is rarely competent to illustrate a larger principle however .
so studying history , watching documentaries , seeing photographs , speaking to survivors of the dirty 30's ... it's all just :
Quote: Anecdotal evidence .... It is rarely competent to illustrate a larger principle however .
(not my words)
hbg
No. I probably expressed that badly. You started out with an anecdotal story and it was that which you used as the reason the Canadian healthcare system was devleoped. It was to that I intended to refer.
The point is that when I was a kid, and my kids were kids, healthcare was handled mostly as I described. And we nevertheless developed a healthcare system that was the envy of the world. There is something both ennobling and practical about paying your own way as much as you are able. Knowing that we would have that $5 charge meant that we didn't run to the doctor for every little thing but only when we knew we had a problem. And because we had that copay at the hospital, we received an itemized copy of our bill and challenged the $10 aspirin or the medication that was never administered or the charge for something that was never prescribed.
If we went back to that system of paying for ordinary repairs and maintenance on ourselves as we do for our automobiles, and saved the insurance for the big stuff that we can't afford, I think both medical costs and the costs of insurance would come way down.
But that isn't in the plan our government seems hellbent on mandating for us. And it appears they will also do away with the medical savings accounts that help folks pay those small repair and maintenance costs up front.