@nat hale,
Fascinating topic - I can see where most everyone is coming from.
With regards to whether are woman likes it when you are respectful - most do. Don't mistake that as being that 'thing' that attracts women. It's necessary for a healthy relationship, but it's not the attactant (ie the thing that gets a woman on 'into you')
In relation to being a gentleman - one of the points of difference between peoples thoughts so far is their definition of 'gentleman', some definitions being :
- considerate, kind, and gentle
- pandering to the woman to please her
- a social categorisation that restricts a mans behaviour regardless of his individuality
Personally, I look at it this way :
In any relationtship there are 3 identities - individual 1, individual 2, and the relationship. This is distinctly different from the forumla as individual 1 + individual 2 = the relationship. Each individual exists separate from the relationship, and together with another individual they contribute their individuality and create a relationship.
The value that you bring to a relationship is your individuality, your world, your creation of your life... imagine a relationship subsuming all that? (it happens...they are the people that have to 'find themselves again' after the relationship ends).
Point being, the reality is a woman is attracted to 'your world', 'your creation', 'who you are'...
...now...imagine doing something in order to 'please' a woman...when you did this, what happened to 'your world', 'the creation of who you are' etc?
...now...imagine doing something that is entirely of your creation from the very essence of who you are...that pleases a woman, not because you want to please the woman, but
because it is who you are...