@parados,
parados wrote:
Quote:It is true that Queen Bees everywhere have tolerated higher taxes as a consequence of their success and most don't complain about that. But it has to be profitable for the Queen Bee to hire that line cook or any other employee. Raise the cost of doing business, including taxes, a great deal less profitable, and Queen Bee may decide it just isn't worth it to stay open the extra hours or do the additional investment or take on more risk; she scales back or doesn't expand and the line cook's job is eliminated or is never created.
You act as if the Queen Bee pays for the business 0ut of the $100,000. That is what she makes AFTER she pays for the business. As was pointed out, making $85,000 instead of $90,000 after taxes doesn't raise the costs of her business because that is a separate item. Raise the cost of doing business and her profit goes down so she pays less taxes.
You seem to think that the Queen Bee pays herself a salary and that $85,000 or $90,000 is what she has to spend above and beyond the cost of doing business. Normally people earning in this range are sole proprietors or LLCs in which all earnings are taxed as ordinary income. But she has to plan ahead to use some of this money for future investments, upgrades, new equipment or whatever. So she pays taxes on it, but it is not all hers to spend however she wishes unless she wishes to put the business at higher risk.
This is the fallacy of the whole tax more only those making $250,000 and up concept. People in that range will mostly be small businesses with expenses including a few employees. They pay a hefty income tax on that plus self employment tax in lieu of employer matched social security contributions and that is always a substantial hit. You can dodge some of that by organizing as an S Corp and paying yourself a salary. That does help in dodging some self employment taxes but if you pay yourself $40,000 you're still going to owe taxes of more than $6k for self employment tax PLUS income taxes on the combined total of wages and share distribution and if there is anything left over in the corporation, you will owe corporate taxes on that too.
The United States has the second highest business taxes in the world. The top 5% of wage earners in the USA already pay more than 50% of the taxes. the top 50% of wage earners in the USA pay more than 96% of the taxes.
And as we are obviously slogging through a recession, why would anybody think raising taxes on anybody was the thing to do but certainly why would you raise taxes on the few people who are in a position to help keep the stock market afloat and keep tens of thousands of Americans working?