Joe Nation wrote:OCCOM BILL wrote:dlowan wrote:I knew that would make the revenge freaks happy.
And here one of them is to gloat.
Rah rah rah indeed.

Revenge freak? Talk about a twisted spin. From what I read; there was no victim to avenge (thank Good). I have no way of knowing if he acted on his sick desires in the past, nor even if he would have this time. But I am very glad he removed the possibility of
next time. You more enlightened folks can look down your noses at me all you wish, but I'll continue to view the self-removal of pedophiles as the single most decent thing they can do for the team. His last act was in all likelihood the most noble thing he's ever done.
This is the oddest and, to use your word,
twisted opinion you have ever offered.
You would prefer suicide as a method of justice.
Joe(shall each prisoner be left alone with a length of rope?)Nation
That really
IS interesting.
From observation of history,
we know that a significant proportion
of criminals have attempted suicide.
Many of their attempts have succeeded.
What r the arguments pro & con ? ( no pun )
The first n most obvious: financial convenience
for the taxpayers.
The second has already been mentioned:
avoiding recidivism.
A con is that an innocent man who is depressed
over his misfortune and the calumny against his reputation
attendant to having been arrested for alleged child molestation
in the vu of his family, friends, neighbors and business associates
may move him to abort his earthly life.
Another consideration is that a man may wish to avoid
the violent sexual molestation that prisoners expect
to have visited upon them in prison after a sentence for child rape,
regardless of the guilt or innocence of the prisoner.
( I don 't know whether that is a pro or a con. )
As a nation, and as a world, our consensus has been
that capital punishment is
the most severe penalty
hence, if a guilty man adopts it,
then he is accepting
a more severe revenge upon himself than incarceration;
( i.e., he is not getting away with it ).
People who have unsuccessfully attempted suicide
have told us of observing hellish circumstances in retribution for that act.
Any additional pros or cons ?
Comments ?
Questions ?