blatham wrote:When the population of a sovereign nation have notions and wishes such as we see below, how ought we to value those wishes and notions?
Ought we to ignore them, desiring what is good for
them while presuming we know better than they what is good for them?
Ought we to ignore them, but do so because we are acting in our own interests in occupying that sovereign nation (meanwhile, for the obvious PR reasons, pretending otherwise)?
Ought we, on the principle of respect for freedom and sovereignty, to act in accordance with their wishes/notions?
Blatham, this survey you posted here failed to report the Iraq people's "notions and wishes" in response to the question: "What do you believe would happen in Iraq if the United States quickly withdrew its forces?"
I think the people of UAE, KSA, Morocco, Lebanon, Jordan, and Egypt are unreliable sources for determining the "notions and wishes" of the Iraq people.
You asked the following four questions:
1. When the population of a sovereign nation have notions and wishes such as we see below, how ought we to value those wishes and notions?
But the actual "notions and wishes" of the Iraq people were not reported here.
2. Ought we to ignore them, desiring what is good for
them while presuming we know better than they what is good for them?
We shouldn't rely on people other than the Iraq people to decide what are the "notions and wishes" of the Iraq people.
3. Ought we to ignore them, but do so because we are acting in our own interests in occupying that sovereign nation (meanwhile, for the obvious PR reasons, pretending otherwise)?
We are not ignoring the "notions and wishes" of the Iraq people like you and these pollsters here are.
4. Ought we, on the principle of respect for freedom and sovereignty, to act in accordance with their wishes/notions?
You and these pollsters here lack sufficient evidence to determine that we are not acting in accordance with the "notions and wishes" of the Iraq people.
In the event that a valid survey of the "notions and wishes" of the Iraq people is obtained, and that survey reveals that a clear majority of the Iraq people believe "they will find a way to bridge their differences" if "the United States quickly withdrew its forces," then the United States should quickly withdraw its forces.