eoe wrote:dyslexia wrote:snood wrote:dyslexia wrote:It is well known that Plato, his teacher Socrates, and his student Aristotle, were old pedophiles who lived to have sex with beautiful young boys.
How is this relevant?
It's not.
The relevancy is simply that this is nothing new. Especially in politics, where men in power have always been allowed quite alot of freedom to pursue their particular habits without repurcussion. Until recently.
That raises interesting questions.
There was, in fact, a whole culture supporting ephebophilia...which included, as I understand it, duties and oblligations of the older man toward the younger...thus he was a mentor and teacher.
Also, as I understand it, the ideal was NOT to have a sexual relationship, but to sublimate the feelings into a "higher" bond.
I had understood that Socrates was not supportive of the relationship becoming sexual...though one wonders about Alcibiades...... I do not know anything about Aristotle in this regard.
It also was not especially "men in power" who behaved thus, but mature men of the higher classes...especially as part of the warrior tradition. Of course, they were older and thus had a position of some power.
I do wonder what, if any difference, an honourable (think of the Theban band) cultural place for the emotion, if not the act, had on any damage done to the boys?
Modern paedophiles frequently attempt to use this tradition to justify their behaviour......but I think, in our culture, that this is self-serving bullshit...we would not use Athenian customs of slavery and subjugation of women to justify their resumption today.
In a sense, where the age of consent is placed is somewhat arbitrary, but in my view this arbitrariness is difficult to avoid, and worth bearing with for the sake of the wider good of discouraging sexual abuse.
I am not really sure that you can view ancient Greeks' behaviour through the same lens that we use today...for starters, young men were warriors at an age where our kids are mostly still schoolkids...and pages.
Lord...what a rant!