TAYLOR HICKS ROCKS AMERICAN IDOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

ROFL! Greenwitch, that is hilarious!

Yes, I would have thought Bucky would have gone before Lisa. Lisa had a beautiful voice. Just hadn't found her genre yet.

I do think Ace deserved to be in the bottom three. His version of that song S U C K E D. I can't stand Ace. He is a carbon copy of every boy band ever made.

And my favorite boy Chris is getting really boring.

Ace sucked is right. I don't even know what song he sang. He's really working that look of his though. Do love those eyes.

I hear you about Chris. Would like to see him do something really different. Wonder if he can?

Okay, that's it! I am back to hating Simon again! Boring, lazy????? Not my Taylor!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

True, not the best song choice. Many other songs could have shown off his voice much better, but he still got a standing ovation!!!!!!!!! Doesn't that count???????????

Man!

Mandisa doing Shania Twain! OMG! No Way! I think it was horrible. She is such an awesome singer but that was such a bad choice for her! Someone, please, wake me up!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I know I have to be having a nightmare here!

I am sorry, but I have to say something.

Is Mandissa hiding a dead body in her ASS!? Wait, excuse me, make that TWO dead bodies.

Holy ****, it's freakishly huge! Is it just me?

No kickycan, it's not you. She is a big woman. Worse thing she can do is to wear horizontal stripes! Makes you look twice as wide!

Well, Elliot has impressed me tonight. I'm not swayed over from Taylor, but he gave a fine performance.

Taylor has no chance, my friend. Neither does Elliot. Taylor is uniquely entertaining, but doesn't fit the mold. And although I do want Elliot to win the whole thing, Elliot is ugly, and because of that, he can't win.

And Paris is, of course, the devil.

I know Taylor isn't going to win. But I do like his uniqueness. Hey, he's a southern boy! I gotta hang!

Elliot, you're right I'm afraid.

Paris is the DEVIL????????????? Oh man! I thought the Devil was a he!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Can't believe she tried a Trisha Yearwood song. She did ok, but not great.

Wow! Ace did a fantastic job tonight. He is not one of my favorites but great job.

Okay kickycan, Kellie's up next!

Okay, can we change the title of this thread to "KELLIE PICKLER ROCKS AMERICAN IDOL?"

Awesome job! Just friggin awesome!

This is my girl right here. Katharine is real good.

Real good? Kickycan, if you do not personally go kick Simon's butt, I'm going to lose all my respect for you! What a putz he is! She was absolutely wonderful!

I'll kick his butt as soon as you go up and drag Paula Abdul's drunk ass off the stage for me. Or maybe she's just taken too many quaaludes. I'm not sure which it is, but no one should be allowed to act the way she does.

Okay, I'm not sure about the bottom three right now. I hope Paris is one of 'em. I think I liked Elliot the most tonight, the pour hideous bastard.

Ok, deal. I'll take out Paula and you take out Simon.

Okay my bottom three are:

Paris
Mandisa
Taylor (OMG! I didn't say that out loud, did I?)

It's the truth. He's not living up to his potential and there is a lot of tough competition. Don't think he'll get knocked out this week but he'd better be careful.

To be totally honest, I think Bucky was the best tonight. That song was him. Chris was great as were most of them. But, Bucky really knocked it out of the park.

Oh yeah, if Kellie keeps this up, she's got this thing in the bag!

Whomever dressed Mandisa tonight should be voted off.

Green Witch, I am with you. I can't believe she wore that top! Horizontal stripes on TV of all things! She's such an awesome talent but part of it is the face the public sees.

She has a beautiful face and a classical figure in the earth mother sense:



But (no pun intended), those curvy stripes made her look like a volkswagon.

hehehe

Mandisa did look AWFUL last night. No matter what size you are, you HAVE to wear clothes that compliment your body shape...and that was definitly not a complimetary outfit. Yikes.

Taylor was boring.

Ace was boy band at it's best (although it was an ok performance)

Kellie did good but I didn't feel it was her best performance.

Katherine is my girl and I think she did great vocally but the performance wasn't quite there.

Chris did very well for stepping so far out of his comfort zone...I liked the change up. He is so sexy.

Paris was boring.

Elliot was good, probably one of the top performers.

Mandisa was just ok, which is terrible for her considering her powerhouse voice.

Who am I missing? It must have been a completely unmemorable performance......

Oh Bucky!

I hated it. I can't understand a freakin' word he says ever.

My bottom three?

Bucky
Paris
Taylor