@Memphis-Eleanor ,
I was in an extra marital affair for 7 years. We broke up but are back in it.
I feel your pain.
I know the addiction an affair can be, the pull you have towards this other person.
I know that your marriage can heal but you will likely always have questions / doubts.
It is possible that you can leave your marriage, seek out the other woman, and find it won't work, causing regret and pain.
There is no easy answer here, I am facing the same thing. The odds are against affair relationships, but when you're in one, they feel like pure magic.
I would encourage you to challenge the thoughts that you never loved like you have with this woman, chances are you have, you just forgot. If you make a decision, just know that either way you will have regrets and you will think about it for maybe the rest of your life. In the end, the pain will hurt no matter your choice but affairs are messy and they are discouraged for good reasons. Your life is never going to be the same again, mine won't either.
In many ways I regret the affair, it clouded my view on my own life.
In other ways, I don't think I can live without my affair. It is far too magical and brings me life giving energy every single day.