Very much so. It barely missed my top 10 favorite films from 2019. It's bat sh!t crazy. It's stunning to look at (and well deserves the cinematography nomination though it ain't taking the win from Roger Deakin's 1917).
The acting was jaw droppingly stunning. Willem Dafoe needed to be nominated this year but was robbed. It made me finally respect Robert Pattinson as an actor for the first time ever.
I get why some people would balk on how over the top freaky the story is and it's not a horror movie ... closer to horror movie adjacent. But to me? It works very well. Even the seagull gave an Oscar worthy performance.
I'm guessing you didn't remember I posted this in the actual Lighthouse thread where you posted a response afterwards?