@blatham,
Quote Blickers, [to Lash]:
Quote:Hey, Edgar just posted the same stupid article a few days ago in this very thread!
Quote blatham:
Quote:I wouldn't label that as a "stupid" article (and I don't think AlterNet is a stupid source of information/opinion). Perhaps you use the term a bit differently than is the normal use.
But I would say it is unbalanced by an underlying idealism.
The article in question, which was basically 15 reasons why somebody didn't like Clinton's presidency, deserved the "stupid" label when the reader hits reason #8, where the author complained about Clinton getting involved in the awful war in Bosnia followed by several of the former Iron Curtain countries joining the EU and NATO. Before Clinton decided to prod NATO into doing something, there was blood running in the streets in the same area which touched off World War One, and this place is in Europe, which is supposed to an advanced place. Ethnic cleansing was taking place, and paramilitaries were going from town to town slaughtering people. After Clinton and NATO got in, the bloodletting soon came to a close and the Dayton Accords finalized a solution that is still holding up. No American losses in the process. The author of the article, (and Lash), apparently objects to this.
Further, the former Iron Curtain countries were definitely under pressure to be put into some kind of Russian economic orbit after they finally able to wrest free of USSR /Russian domination in 1991. Entering into an economic/political orbit with Russia would be a disaster for them since Russia has never in its history ever been able to achieve a good standard of living for its people. By accepting these countries' application to the EU, the West opened up prosperity for these nations they had never known, and by accepting their application to NATO, these countries are now safe from Russia trying to take them back militarily.
Take a look at the GDP of the Czech Republic since 1991, when they broke free of USSR / Russian domination:
The chart starts at 1996, but you can see GDP was not rising before 200o or so.
It took them a little while to get moving once they shook free of the USSR / Russia, but they soon started recovering and really picked up steam after 2004, when they joined the EU. Growth flattened after the 2008 crash but it's picking up again, and overall the Czechs are WAY ahead of where they were when they were in the Russian orbit.
The author of the article that Edgar and Lash endorsed thinks this is a BAD thing, that the US and the West should have let the factions in the former Yugoslavia cut each other's throats with impunity and we should have let Russia make its play to re-absorb the Iron Curtain countries instead of offering them membership in the prosperous EU and NATO. There are over 100 Million people in those countries, and the articles' author thought we should have abandoned them for fear of Russia getting upset about it.
And he thinks Clinton blundered here, did a bad thing. It makes about as much sense as blaming Lincoln for forcefully proclaiming Emancipation Proclamation, instead of treating the Confederate states nicely and hoping they will evolve an anti-slavery stance on their own someday.
That is why I labelled this a "stupid" article.