@firefly,
Ok, so I'm working 3 jobs now and haven't been checking in here because I'm busy.
You're asking me an honest question firefly, so I'll give you my honest opinion. But I'll give it here because that's where the question was posed.
I really wish I had never mentioned my race, because it's irrelevant to almost every point I've been trying to make during my time on A2K. I've noticed some topics here about race (such as the Michael Brown shooting), but have purposely decided not to comment. That being said, I can't take the information that I've shared back. And so you all know that I'm a black man. I realize that colors what I have to say. This was a misjudgement on my part, because now when I speak, you are imagining a black man saying it, and that indeed "colors" what I'm trying to say. When there really is no "color" to my message at all. I'm a man before I'm a black man. Most every point I've tried to make here on A2K is that men are human beings with intrinsic value/human worth. All men deserve the same human rights as women do. If I'm going to be pigeonholed as something, I prefer to be known as a man who values his fellow men (no matter what their race, sexual orientation, etc, etc.)
Quote:3) I believe that the black victim story has lost all of its credibility during my lifetime, we should move on, and so should our language
So I would disagree (in part) with hawkeye here. Speaking as an African American, I have been subject to quite a bit of prejudice during my lifetime. So no, I don't think black victimhood has lost ALL it's credibility. However, I DO think that as a black man, when I speak out about disadvantages that I face, they are taken
much more seriously than a man in my exact same social position who might happen to be white. And that's why I regret disclosing my race. I want my words to speak for themself without some perceived "victimhood" attached to them. Because I don't consider myself to be a victim.
I think if anything, what hawkeye is "guilty" of here is choosing the "wrong" words. And as far as I see, that is not significant enough for me to even raise an eyebrow to it (I'm only explaining this to you to try give you some personal understanding as best I can.) People sometimes may not find the perfect words to say, but you have to look more at the MESSAGE they're putting forth rather than the manner in which they do so.
And see that's the thing about gynocentrism and specifically the female indoctrination of language, and politically correct social behavior. (Now bear in mind I'm making a generalization here OMG!!! I'm fully aware that not ALL females fit this model, but just because there are exceptions to a given rule, does not discredit the rule as a whole. ANY scientist who collects data, makes "generalizations" based on the data available to him/her in order to form hypotheses.) Females appear (for the most part) to be concerned more with HOW things are said rather than WHAT is being said. That is to say that they are more concerned with using specific language to try to not offend people rather than being concerned with saying something MEANINGFUL. This has a lot to do with the different ways that men and women consume information (both verbal and nonverbal). And because women are, and ALWAYS have been the limiting factor in human reproduction (along with a laundry list of other reasons that I'm not going to list here simply because they would take up too much space), society is GYNOCENTRIC (i.e. it caters to women's best interests above men's, including valuing female life above male life.) So because of this, society has it's arm twisted to comply with this "pretty" manner of speaking about things rather than being allowed to be frank/direct, even if that means using non-politically correct language to get **** done.
I don't give a flying **** if hawkeye uses the word Nigger or not. I have yet to get the impression that hawkeye is racist AT ALL. Context matters. And even
if the context were to be racist/bigoted, I don't feel I have the right to tell someone they aren't allowed to use certain words. because the minute I do that, I give up my own personal freedom to criticise that racism/bigotry through my own free speech.
Hawkeye states:
Quote:My opinion is that words should never be banned
Words/language
SHOULD NOT be censored. When you start down that path, it becomes open season on free speech, and a free exchange of ideas. I enjoy being able to say whatever I choose. If people don't like what I'm saying, well then they can choose not to pay attention to me. Just like I already know not to take people who say bigoted things seriously. Because I don't hold hate in my own personal heart, and therefore I recognize that stuff as nonsense. But I don't want my ability to criticize those hateful messages to be taken away, and that's why I believe that those idiots have a right to say whatever they choose to.
The truth is that straight men (probably even more so white, straight men) are the current "niggers" of the world. When they face problems, they're just crying "Male Tears". They are blamed and scapegoated for everything under the sun. They are viewed as the 'villains' in almost every narrative being sold to the public. They are the boogie men who are all rapists, and who are holding everyone else down with their "privilege". It's socially acceptable to slur and openly hate them.
Even though I have
far less social safety nets available to me than women do, I'm aware that in the context of a cultural narrative I have more empathy available to me for the struggles that I face in terms of how society views me than a white man in my exact same socio-economic situation.