@firefly,
firefly wrote:I don't know many women who view catcalls or comments on the street about their appearance or bodies as "sincere compliments" or "merely an aesthetic appreciation". Those things do make most women feel uncomfortable most of the time--based on my own experience, as well as the reactions of all the other women I've known. Yes, if you feel you do look good, and you've taken pains to look attractive, a single wolfwhistle might not bother you, and you might regard that as flattery, but most of the time, unsolicited remarks or reactions from total strangers on the street make women feel acutely self conscious and somewhat anxious about the fact their bodies are being viewed and commented on in that objectified way, and it does make them feel more vulnerable.
Granted. But that sort of juvenile and puerile cat-calling isn't what soundsighted seems to be talking about when he says:
Quote: There should be some sort of penalty for men who compliment women on the street. Because even if it's just saying "Hope you have a nice evening sweetheart.", that's an invasion of a woman's personal space, and it's in the same realm of violation as rape is.
To identify something as relatively innocent as an offhanded compliment with rape is to minimize the seriousness of rape, imo. And to suggest that "there should be some sort of penalty" for this lack of common courtesy smacks of an endorsement of a fascistic dictatorial society.
You wrote:
Quote:If that's the sort of body commentary and behavior exhibited by our most venerable law makers, toward their female colleagues, and those females working around them, can you imagine what women in other walks of life, and college women, are forced to put up with all the time? Is it any wonder that it has taken so long to get this old boys network on Capital Hill so long to address issues of sexual assault and sexual harrassment in the military and on campuses at all? And that that fight is still spearheaded by female members of the Senate--like Senator Kirsten Gillibrand, and Senator Claire McCaskill--who understand the importance of this issue from a woman's perspective, because it's mainly women who get sexually assaulted.
It's no secret that the halls of Congress are hot-beds (pardon the expression) of sexist behavior; the deplorable behavior of our lawmakers makes the news on a virtually constant basis. I don't believe, based on my own experience, that "women in other walks of life" are routinely subject to similar unwelcome attention. I have personally seen more than one man get fired for coming on just a bit too strong to female colleagues. Senators and Representatives, as elected officials, aren't concerned about getting fired and have grossly exaggerated images of their own omnipotence anyway.
I generally agree with you on all issues, firefly. I think you know that. I think you also know that I am hardly a sexist. But this soundsighted character's posts are so off-the-wall I can't let them pass unchallenged.