@Setanta,
Quote:Iconic has become meaningless--rather like awesome was rendered meaningless in the 1960s and -70s, when it was used without regard to whether the product or person referred to actually inspired awe. Same thing with iconic these days.
Meaningless piffle from one of the A2K masters of piffledom. "X has become meaningless" - now where have we heard that before? And no attribution.
If all these words have become 'meaningless', how is it that people still use them, frequently and those that hear them understand?
Quote:If you know what an icon is, then you'll understand.
I do, know, that is. I have a bunch of them on my desktop and I don't get the least bit confused when the word is used in different contexts.
The advent of [desktop-computer] icon hasn't made the other meanings meaningless. All it has done is add one more meaning to the list for 'icon'.
Any English speaker with half a brain knows that words can have many meanings. This doesn't cause puzzlement for five year olds but it confuses the hell out of Setanta.
Quote:Iconic is used these days as some sort of intensifier of praise. I routinely hear someone's first music album or motion picture being described as iconic. Not compared to a genre and said to be iconic; not compared to a body of work (there is none to compare to when it's the first) and described as iconic--just described as iconic because the speaker wishes to praise it.
Why is it that there is a decided shortage of examples from this guy who "routinely" hears what will, in all certainty, be the death knell for the English language?