JTT wrote:
Clary,
The likelihood that anybody anywhere on the planet today is pronouncing Latin as it was spoken back when it was a living language is exceedingly low, approaching zero.
Even those with a classical education are so deeply influenced by their own native language sound system that it's impossible to capture the sound system of another language, especially a dead one. How old were you when you began the study of Latin?
JTT,
Does it never occur to you that register is important when addressing people? If you read what you have written and imagine it was addressed to you, would you not feel that it was patronising?
I am a mature person, and have studied Romance Philology in some depth. I don't choose to pontificate on these matters, because that is inappropriate for the spirit of these threads. You are using lecturer register without, seemingly, being aware that your interlocutors are not students.
Your points are blindingly obvious. But I prefer a discussion, a putting out of thoughts, to a guru-chela system, and judging by the animosity which snakes its way through this thread like a black worm, so do other posters here.
However, I wish you good day and a good digestion.
JTT wrote:Have you ever noticed how foreigners sound foreign?
Yes. Is this a rhetorical question, and will it lead to a lecture on phonology?