@edgarblythe,
edgarblythe wrote:
Do they sell single slice toasters?
I think this is the answer. Make your toast one slice at a time. You know you want to.
When your true love is there, spread and offer her the first slice (of course you would!)
Then - put another slice in the toaster, stand there like a dill, (or gaze lovingly at her as she enjoys that first slice of hot, buttered toast) and wait for it to toast, then remove, spread, eat.
This is not so good for the planet - but what's that compared to this problem you have.