Steve (as 41oo) wrote:Moishe asks me
Quote:Why do you believe that establishing a Jewish State was wrong?
Because among other things, its against the Will of G-d.
http://www.jewsagainstzionism.com/
This is one of the most pertinent things you have written.
I's wrong, but very pertinent.
The reason it's wrong is because who are you (or in this case "they") to decied what is the Will of G-d?
To wit - a quote selected at random from your website (mainly because I learn the Chofetz Chaim a lot):
I have also learned over some of Reb Elchonon, quoted above.
Based on my understanding of what the Chofetz Chaim said and wrote above, YOU would be condemned for claiming that establishing a Jewish IS (my emphasis) wrong and against the Will of G-d.
If you are enough of a Jewish scholar to have actually read what the rabbis said about establishing a Jewish state and their references to the Torah, then you ought to be enough of a scholar to figure out the difference between WAS and IS in reference to whether the Rabbis today believe that it is the Will of G-d that the state of Israel exists and whether it should continue to exist.
