@hawkeye10,
I really can't understand why you're attempting to make such a big issue out of this, hawkeye.
Your authorities were responding to initial forecasts ....
at the time.
Which were rather dire, yes?
I tend to agree with the "damned if they do, damned if they don't" assessment of others here.
The government is not God, it couldn't have known, based on the initial forecasts, that the force of Irene would weaken.
I think it was a case of the authorities covering their own backs. And why wouldn't they?
If the worst
had happened, & they hadn't issued the warnings they did, they would have been held responsible for any deaths which might have occurred.
Now, given the worst
hasn't happened, you're complaining that they were too heavy-handed.
Give us a break.
In my state (Victoria, Oz) during the 2009 "Black Saturday" bushfires, over 200 homes were destroyed & over 150 people died.
For days beforehand, the weather bureau, the state premier, media reporting, told us we in for an incredibly hot, windy & dangerous day on Saturday. How anyone, especially people who lived in bushfire-prone areas, wasn't aware that an extremely dangerous time could well be ahead , I don't know.
The usual practice has been Fire authorities warnings to residents to "leave or stay" ... leave their homes in areas under threat by 10 am, or decide to stay, having taken the prescribed measures. A personal decision.
Many of those who stayed to protect their homes died. In any case, by the time the full intensity of the fires became evident, later in the day, it would have been way too late to evacuate, anyway.
The government & the fire authorities have come under intense pressure & criticism, from a Royal Commission & from the community, for not giving residents adequate warning.
I suspect that the next time we face a similar event (& we will), mandatory evacuation will be required by the authorities, to cover their own backs. Just like in NYC.
I also suspect, that if the dangerous weather conditions subside during the day & it turns out to
not be another "Black Saturday", that there will be those who (just like you) will complain about the authorities "overreacting".
It seems pretty hard for the authorities to "win" with some people.