No place for class divide in justice
Miranda Devine
Sunday Herald
Sun May 22, 2011
THERE was something so refreshingly egalitarian about the arrest of International Monetary Fund chief Dominique Strauss-Kahn at New York's JFK Airport last week.
The famous French socialist was luxuriating in a first-class seat in Air France's L'Espace Premier cabin, glass of Billecart-Salmon Brut Vintage in hand, soft lights, piped music, flight attendants fluttering around and Michelin-starred menus.
Then in stomped New York's finest and hauled him off the plane.
France was outraged and sophisticated intellectuals the world over condemned the barbaric US justice system that considers the welfare of a poor immigrant hotel maid more important than the dignity of an entitled French banker.
It seems immaterial to Strauss-Khan's instant defenders that the haughty, jetsetting bureaucrat has been accused of a despicable crime - attempting to rape the 32-year-old maid who came to clean his $3000-a-night penthouse suite at New York's swanky Sofitel.
He sexually assaulted her and tried to rape her, prosecutors allege.
Unable to remove her pantyhose, he forced her to perform oral sex.
Strauss-Khan's lawyers claimed the maid consented to these indignities, as the 62-year-old financier was released on bail into home detention in a rented Manhattan apartment.
But like the Roman Polanski under-age rape case, Strauss-Khan's arrest has been just another opportunity to sneer at the US's puritanism.
Again we see the world split - between narcissistic Left-wing elites who believe justice is flexible and people like them should be able to do whatever they like, and the rest of us, who believe in equality under the law and that vulnerable people should be protected.
There is Strauss-Khan, the wealthy, thrice-married womaniser expected to run as the Socialist candidate for the French presidency next year. And there is the alleged victim, a devout Muslim who lives in an insalubrious flat in the Bronx and works to support a teenage daughter with whom she escaped Guinea and the kind of violence she allegedly met in the room she was trying to clean.
According to her lawyer, she is a "very proper, dignified young woman". Her neighbours described her as modest and quiet.
Strauss-Khan, aka DSK, is one of those silver-tongued Billecart-Salmon socialists who talks theoretically about the gap between rich and poor while living off our tax dollars - yes, our dollars.
The IMF is funded to the tune of $750 billion from developed countries such as Australia, which pours in tens of billions of dollars each year.
FRENCH intellectuals such as Bernard-Henri Levy are screaming blue murder about the "disgraceful" treatment of the (former) IMF president.
Levy is angry with the US judge "who ... pretended to take (DSK) for a subject of justice like any other".
Even on our ABC, discussion of the Strauss-Kahn case trivialised the plight of the victim.
ABC 702 radio host Deb Cameron equated Strauss-Kahn to Arnold Schwarzenegger -- men whose careers have been "undone by infidelity", as if the IMF chief was just accused of having nookie on the side.
DSK is innocent until proven guilty but in France, where it appears his behaviour has long been tolerated, other victims came forward last week to describe the powerful banker as sex-crazed.
Journalist Tristane Banon has reportedly hired a lawyer over an alleged sexual assault by DSK when she was 22.
"We fought on the floor, it was not just a couple of slaps. I kicked him. He tried to undo my bra, he also tried to open my jeans. When we were fighting, I said the word rape to him to frighten him, but it didn't seem to frighten him at all. Later, he wouldn't stop texting me, saying, 'Are you scared of me?'," she said.
She said all that four years ago on a French talk show and no one batted an eyelid.
The New York Times reports that a culture of predatory behaviour against women existed at the IMF under Strauss-Khan.
Women were apparently so intimidated by his aggressive sexual advances that they did not wear skirts and made sure never to be caught alone with him.
One woman left the IMF with a generous payout after complaining of being pressured to sleep with him.
But to American financial commentator Ben Stein, it is inconceivable that a banker as eminent as DSK could be guilty of a crime.
On the other hand, many hotel maids "are complete lunatics, stealing airline tickets, stealing money, throwing away important papers, stealing medication ... This is a case about the hatred of the have-nots for the haves and that's what it's all about".
No, this case is about the fact that just because people talk about liberty, equality and fraternity, it doesn't mean they mean it.
In fact those who lecture most about the evils of capitalism and the need to reduce consumption and slow progress are like the pervert moralisers of old - the last people to listen to.
This is the beauty of the US and Australia, the most successful immigrant nations. No matter how powerful and important, no one is above the law.
http://www.heraldsun.com.au/opinion/no-place-for-class-divide-in-justice/story-e6frfhqf-1226060335324