@izzythepush,
Quote:You're not being fair here. This is not about keeping details of politically powerful figures hidden, this is about the right to a fair trial
I wasn't referring to the French criminal justice system. I was really referring to the French privacy laws, that do stifle the ability of French journalists to write and talk about, and investigate, the private lives of powerful and influential public figures and politicians. Consequently, many "secrets" in those private lives, remain hidden from the public, and the voters, and this lack of disclosure may conceal information which is relevant to leadership ability or judgment or character on the part of these public figures. I would much rather have the more intrusive, and investigative, U.S. journalism that subjects our public figures and politicians to much closer scrutiny, because I feel such disclosure of information is necessary, and that it is an additional safeguard against abuse of power.
In the U.S. we do not feel that merely knowing the fact of an arrest, or seeing a photo of someone in police custody, deprives someone of the right to a fair trial. Jury selection is carefully done, by both the prosecution and defense, to eliminate those possibly influenced by pre-trial publicity, jurors are instructed not to listen to or discuss news of the trial, or they are sequestered, and the presumption of innocence is stressed in court. If necessary, gag orders can be imposed that prevent the prosecution and defense from publicly discussing the case with the media. Our criminal justice system is open--our courtrooms are open to the public, and we have had entire trials broadcast on television (we used to have a cable channel that broadcast nothing except trials)--and I much prefer it that way.
Other countries have different mores, different procedures, and different laws. I'm not surprised that some in France were shocked to see photos of Strauss-Kahn in handcuffs, being treated like a common criminal--although anyone familiar with American TV crime dramas or movies shouldn't be surprised--that is how we do things here--all those accused of crimes, regardless of their social status, receive similar treatment.
My local paper prints the names of everyone arrested in this jurisdiction for any sort of crime--driving while intoxicated, burglary, petit larceny, assault, etc.--sometimes along with a mug shot photo--even though these people are all presumed innocent prior to trial. For a while, another paper printed the names of all those arrested for patronizing a prostitute. And, it doesn't matter the social status of these people--they will all be treated in an equal fashion.
Other countries follow different rules, and all systems have their pros and cons. I am not suggesting that other countries do things the way they are done in the U.S., but I do feel that our system works well here. And, at the moment, Strauss-Kahn is in our criminal justice system and he will have to live with that.