@parados,
parados wrote:
Trump said everyone. That word is simple enough and it was confirmed by his spokesman. Unless you think Trump doesn't mean what he says, I suppose.
It was reported by several news agencies before he updated his meaning the next day.
That still leaves you ignoring the religious test that Trump is imposing on people. Do you think you can ignore the Constitution like Trump?
So, he never said explicitly that American Muslims who left the country couldn't return.
As I said, I don't believe the first Amendment was supposed to apply to non-citizens not in the country in the sense of forcing us to admit them. In fact, we could stop admitting anyone. Coming here is a privilege, not a right. Didn't Carter once bar all Iranians from coming in? Furthermore, Trump doesn't mean permanently. He means temporarily until we get a handle on the situation, which probably means until we have some better tools to vet them as non-terrorists. Trump is observing that the number of Muslims committing acts of terror is disproportionate to their presence. Profiting from experience is not irrational or improper. I don't know if I would do the same thing, but I don't think that it's unconstitutional.
I do, on the other hand, think that seeking to overturn popular votes or votes of various Congresses based on the
imaginary presence of a guarantee of same sex marriage in the Constitution is a violation of the Constitution. The Constitution says only what it actually says and nothing more.