@chai2,
I feel like I am discussing this with a bunch Sarah Palins. Let's look at facts here.
The poster was asking about voluntary sex in a committed relationship with a partner that is about her age. It is her body, and this is her decision. Someone accused me of giving her a "free pass". All I am saying is that this is her body, and her decision. If this is a free pass, then fine.
Now fine, 14 is a little young. I checked and only about 1 in 10 teenagers have sex at this age. If she waits, it is probably a good thing (I think I made this clear from the start).
Teenagers need real facts about sex so they can make responsible decisions on their own (and no this does not mean that adults make the decisions for them). Trying to hype the fear of diseases and the risk of pregnancy are counterproductive.
Why not tell teenagers the truth?
A person with a single partner using condoms is at a very low risk of an STD. This is true for someone in their 20s, and the risk is probably even lower for teenagers with teen aged partners. If you are going to have sex, then use a condom (I hope we are all in agreement here). But there is no reason to exaggerate the risk.
Let's get real. Only 10% of kids say they are sexually active at 14. But, by age 17 this number is over 50%. Teenagers have sex. This has always been true through the Victorian period and through the rigid 1950s, it is part of human nature.
What's important is not stopping it, but making sure that people have what they need to make responsible decisions for themselves.