real life wrote:Having cheap slave labor is not a 'need' in this country. It is a want. We want luxury and convenience and the illusion that something can be had for nearly nothing.
And unscrupulous businesses want the luxury of illegal workers that they don't have to pay taxes on when they hire them for cash daily. Illegal workers are so much easier to control. They don't talk back or ask for the day off.
It is the same argument used to justify overseas sweatshops 'Americans need these goods'. No they don't . They want them.
Amen to all of that!
All this, however, to me is also a reason why the fight against illegal immigration should start and focus on those "unscrupulous businesses", on the employers who hire these people -- and that includes the people who hire an illegal cleaner or gardener.
Maybe it should even be on the consumers too, with shaming campaigns aimed at shoppers that target those retail companies that have been shown to hire illegals. Hit them in the wallet and they'll soon tighten up.
I think it's unfair but moreover, pretty useless to aim the sharp stick of repression at the illegal immigrants themselves. They're just desperate to find a way out of poverty and help their family back home to survive. And as long as unscrupulous and lazy businesses keep hiring them, they will keep coming, no matter how high a fence you put up and how many people end up dying on their way to get there. It's just a function of the wealth gap between the US and Latin America.
The only effective answer and the only humane answer must focus on the businesses that hire illegals, to start with the bigger corporations. If current laws make it hard for business owners to verify people's legal status (eg, it's not allowed to ask them for their passport or the like), those should be changed, but actually tackling those who knowingly hire illegal immigrants with some urgency would already help a lot, more than any fence would.
And it's on this count, unsurprisingly, that the Bush administration has failed wholesale. Viscerally averse to discomfiting big business in any way, the Bush administration has put all programs that check, chase and fine businesses, whether it is about environmental standards, illegal immigrants or labour regulation, on the back burner or actively discouraged them. In comparison with this, the fence is a populist side show to rally conservative voters without tackling the problem of illegal immigration at its root.