Butrflynet wrote:mysteryman wrote:And there is nobody alive in the US today that remembers being "chained to slave ships and beaten in cotton fields".
So why should those of us who were not alive then and had nothing to do with it be held responsible?
Using that logic, there is nobody alive in the US or Mexico today that remembers the Battle of the Alamo or the Texas Revolution so does that mean the Republic of Texas is non-existant and all Mexicans are not to be held responsible for minding the border? Should all be welcomed back into Mexican Texas where they can build for themselves because nobody alive remembers those events and doesn't want to be held responsible?
Thats one hell of a stretch on your part, but since you apparently didnt understand my post I will try again.
There is nobody alive today that was a slave in the US, period.
Therefore, what our ancestors did over 150 years ago has no bearing on us today.
To continue to blame your anger on something that happened over a century ago is irrational and just plain wrong.
To expect me to feel guilty for what happened so long ago is just plain stupid.
I didnt do it, nor did anyone in my family.
Dont hold me responsible.
As for the example you gave, lets examine that for a minute.
You said...
Quote:Using that logic, there is nobody alive in the US or Mexico today that remembers the Battle of the Alamo or the Texas Revolution
You are absolutely correct, there is nobody alive today that took part in those events or that has firsthand knowledge of them.
So, those events, while interesting from a historical perspective, have absolutely no bearing on life today.
The events happened, nobody denies that, but to continue to live your life today based on your anger for events that happened 170 years ago is absolutely insane.
Quote:so does that mean the Republic of Texas is non-existant and all Mexicans are not to be held responsible for minding the border?
Actually, the independent country called the Republic of Texas does not exist.
Texas became part of the US in 1845, ending the Republic of Texas as an independent country.
Mexicans, Americans, Canadians, Germans, Kenyans, etc. All people are responsible for "minding the border" of their own country and not illegally entering another country.
So I have absolutely no idea what you meant by that.
Quote:Should all be welcomed back into Mexican Texas where they can build for themselves because nobody alive remembers those events and doesn't want to be held responsible
Not wanting to be held responsible for events that happened before you were born and having no knowledge of those events are not the same thing.
We all know that Texas won its independence from Mexico, but that doesnt mean we are responsible today for that decision made 170 years ago.
We all know that slavery existed in this country, but that doesnt mean that we are responsible for it today.
Acknowledging that something happened is not the same as being responsible for it happening, especially when that something happened long before you were born.