nappyheadedhohoho wrote:So will you stand by your theory that it's the "right wing media" that takes it into the fever swamp, just as Marty Peretz is praising Obama for standing by his man? (And taking plenty of heat for it).
Rhetorical question.
Rhetorical? Hardly. Let me guess: you dont actually know much about Peretz, right, apart from that he writes for "the liberal New Republic"?
I've been astounded by Peretz's embrace of Obama - and even more by his defense of Obama's refusal to disavow Wright. Pleasantly astounded, mind - but still, very, very surprised.
Why? Because Peretz is somewhere to the right of Joe Lieberman about most any topic to do with Muslims, war, blacks, or any number of other subjects. (He was in fact the driving force behind the magazine's endorsement of Lieberman, of all persons, in the Democratic primaries of '04.)
So seriously - any attempt to use Peretz's blog on TNR as an example of how 'even people in the liberal media think that [etc]' falls flat on its face.
For years on end now, Peretz has used his blog on the TNR site,
The Spine, as a bully pulpit to lambast Iraq war opponents, liberals, The Nation, Jimmy Carter, Jesse Jackson, anyone remotely critical of Israel's policies, anyone remotely associated with the liberal "netroots", anyone remotely connectable to traditional black politics, etc. Him and his "mini me" on The Plank, Jamie Kirchik.
Why is he on TNR anyway? Well, uh, he owned the thing. Nobody there to throw him out. But what has been the result? The readers of TNR's other writers and blogs either shun The Spine, or goggle at it. But The Spine, in its turn, has attracted a whole readership of its own, one you'd sooner associate with the National Review than with any liberal audience.
I am sure that Peretz's embrace of Obama already shocked a lot of those readers. His indirect defense of Wright must have positively infuriated many of them. So no, I'm not at all surprised that he got a lot of negative comments. But that says exactly zilch about this not being just about "right wing media"; Peretz
is a rightwing media, all by himself. More often than not, his comments section
is the fever swamp. If you want a comparison, then what you're looking for is the National Review's Charles Murray applauding Obama's race speech - I'm sure he got a lot of angry emails too.