@tsarstepan,
Catfish (2010): I was so expecting to hate or strongly dislike the documentary due to its misdirected marketing and the rumors that it might be a staged mockumentary.
Mockumentaries are fine as a genre of fiction. In fact, they can be great even:
A Mighty Wind (2003);
Best in Show (2000);
Waiting for Guffman (1996); and the most famous of them all,
This is Spinal Tap (1984). But these films don't try and bull the viewer into thinking it could ever or should ever be considered reality and pure fact. Any attempt to pull the wool over our eyes and have the producers and filmmakers claim a film as pure fact AKA documentary and it isn't? That gets my hackles up. So when there were early charges against said film, I became too cynical against the filmmakers claims that this wasn't a work of fiction in guise of a tell all documentary.
Cynically watching the first half, I looked out for obvious flaws or a bit of revealing evidence that would clarify the film's status. But with the second half, (without spoiling anything), the meetings seemed far too genuine. And the controversial twist was far more banal yet still so very moving to be faked.
A pleasently unexpected 10/10!