In places in America where there are the most undocumented workers, the economy is roaring along. I live in Florida, a place awash in the undocumented. Our jobless rate is 3% in the state, the lowest rate in the country, and companies are begging people to come to work.
Don't tell me these people are taking jobs from Americans. They do the jobs that unemployed, lazy Americans turn their backs on. They work in the kitchens; they clean hotel rooms and offices; they pick our crops and watch our children. They provide local American entrepreneurs with a hard-working cadre of willing workers.
Yes, they're here illegally, a crime that's technically a misdemeanor, payable with a fine and deportation. They crossed the border without documentation, and many of them obtained documentation fraudulently. So, show me a victim of these crimes, those of you who are the descendents of immigrants, many of whom arrived undocumented themselves?-but before there was a law against it.
The vast majority of the undocumented don't wear ski masks, don't rob and rape, don't prey on the weak and helpless. They're here to work at jobs that pay twenty times what they could earn in their countries of origin.
If we're that concerned with millions of people who have committed misdemeanor crimes, then what about all the Americans who break our misdemeanor laws? These illegal Americans speed on the highways, jaywalk, and cheat on their income taxes and divorce agreements. Perhaps after we deport all the illegal aliens, we can go after all the illegal Americans and make our transition to a police state complete.
Don't get me wrong: I'm not any happier than most people are with the state of immigration policy in America. We need improved border security. We need background checks of those who are in the country. We also need rational reform, a reform that recognizes the role of the immigrant who comes to America to work, and recognizes the need of some American industries, like the agriculture, hospitality, and construction industries, for low-cost, hard-working workers.
Every worker who comes to America should be documented, and a national registry of these workers can separate the people who are here honestly to work from those who come here with more sinister motives. A national registry of workers allows immigrants looking for work to be matched with jobs that are needed. It reduces and ultimately dries up the motive for illegal border crossings by those looking for work. When an entrepreneur can easily get a legally documented worker, why should he settle for an illegal?
So what should we do with the worker who's here illegally now? There are some eleven to twelve million of them, a logistical nightmare to track down and deport. (Not mention the police state environment that this would create in this country.) Many of them are already established in the country, with employers who count on them. Some are married to Americans and have children who are American citizens.
The answer is not amnesty, but justice. First, register them, document them, background check them. Then charge them with their crime. Make them pay their misdemeanor fine, pay back taxes, and serve community service hours. If they want to become citizens, they must go to the back of the line of those applying for citizenship. The Senate's bill would do all these things.
Once we have our current undocumented aliens documented, and future workers coming in documented in a guest worker program, filling all needed jobs in this country, the job market for illegal aliens dries up. The number of illegal aliens declines to those with truly illegal purposes?-drug smugglers, illegal importers, and terrorists?-and catching them without documentation becomes a manageable law enforcement issue
http://batr.org/twins/041506.html