Setanta wrote:Abid wrote:you are talking without knowledge and if you cannot be bothered to do your research into history to find out how the prophet Mohammed (saw) lived and acted in his life then you really should speak.
PLEASE LOOK AT Post: 2397937 - To see what NON-MUSLIM HISTORIANS WROTE AT ABOUT HIM (saw).
the Arabs were a nation who memorized more than they wrote.
At the time of the prophets (saw) there were THOUSANDS of companions.
TODAY THOUSANDS HAVE MEMORIZED THE QURAN FROM START TO FINISH. IT IS NOT A SMALL BOOK EITHER!!
THE YOUNGEST ON RECORD was 6 YEARS OLD!!!
HOW CAN YOU POSSIBLY BELIEVE THAT ALL THESE PEOPLE, who memorized, could believe something that was not there to begin with!!!! (emoticon removed in the interest of adult conversation)
Muslim historians confirm that your prophet was illiterate. Muslim historians confirmed that he married several times, and married wealthy widows (he was a ne'er-do-well who relied on those widows for his money). Muslim historians confirm that he married a nine-year old girl. He was someone who would be universally condemned in civilized societies if he were alive today.
It is a simple matter to believe that people who memorized something can believe what is not there to begin with. The source of the material they memorize cannot reasonably be considered at the outset to have been reliable, nor free from venal and personally self-agrandizing agendae. With the passage of centuries, there is no basis upon which to assert that nothing was changed, or added, to what was originally the putative "word of god" peddled by an illiterate, violent, sexual predator who preferred to marry widows than to actually earn a decent living on his own.
Your boy Mohammed is far from an admirable creature, and your mindless worship of "the Prophet" is a blasphemy by your own religious terms as you venerate a mere man as though he were a god himself.
Get a clue, your superstition is not superior to anyone else's superstition.
I need a clue?
I makes me laugh when people try their utmost to bring the same orientilist views that you speak of again and again.
If you look back in history, these same arguments have been used again and again.
Check out The Quran and the Orientalists by Dr. M. Mohar Ali
ALL YOUR ARGUMENTS HAVE BEEN DISCUSSED FROM THE BEGINNING OF ISLAM AND WE ARE STILL GROWING IN NUMBER.!!!!
Get a clue???
He (pbuh) slept on a bed of straw, he was offered large sums of money to stop preaching by kings, do you really think honest people will believe he was driven by Money?
As regards to marrying Aiesha (may Allah be pleased with her) at the age of 9. This was a decree from Allah.
The yongest age on record for a person to have a child is in - Argentina at the age of 8!
If a women is menstrating, then in the eyes of God, she is ready to give birth.!
Again, look at the bigger picture. Ayesha (mAbpwh) grew up to be considered as one of the foremost scholars of Islam's early age and is revered as a role model by millions of women.!! She is known to be one of the greatest collector of Hadith (sayings and actions of the prophet)
Her father, Abu Bakr, consented to the marrage, and was the closest friend, like a brother to the prophet!! - He became leader of the Muslims after Mohammeds death.