@layman,
Quote:Maybe you just don't hear so good, ever think of that?
Sort of hard to "hear" something communicated in writing. As I said, I never
heard anyone refer to Hitchins that way. And the reason illustrates the point I was making about "the left".
Counterpunch has made its reputation as being "lefter-than-left" and regularly criticizes liberals and anyone not deemed to be following
its line — but not everyone on the left attends to it that carefully, nor does everyone on the left subscribe to the viewpoints and conclusions reached by the writers who are featured there. There's something pathetic anyway about trying to fit people into tidy little boxes labeled "left" or "right". Most people aren't that doctrinaire and would find no difficulty dismissing some ideas they might read on
Counterpunch while accepting others. Hitchins, warts and all, remains a joy to read. Thanks for the link — I recall something of that controversy but I was never that interested drumming people out of some non-existent "movement" and had completely forgotten about it over the years. As you admit, it predates
Fahrenheit 9/11
EDIT: And most people on "the left" ignore the Socialist Worker's Party as well. It's just a Trotskyist faction and only represents a small space on the leftist spectrum.