@ehBeth,
ehBeth wrote:not a chance of that argument coming from me (partly because I don't think you can separate them out very well)
Yes, it's all a bit foggy, but i guess my point is that some degree of competition is unavoidable and can be healthy, when engaged willingly for instance. Not all "fights" are bad, one should be ready to "fight the right fights", and also there are big and small fights.
When you oversee children playing, you can't in practice suppress all competition or intervene in every dispute. In practice you just intervene when one has been really hurt and cries, and you try to reestablish a degree of justice and harmony in there, post-damage... Now if you note that one particular kid happens to make his/her sister/brother cry a lot, you want to talk to that kid about it and set more stringent rules and punishement. Cause he's not been listening so far so you crank up the volume.
I don't think one should rule out violence among kids, but some rules do apply. This will sound very corny but in my view the correct message to boys about physical violence to girls is the one I was handed as a boy, and handed out to my boy: "You will not fight with girls, because they are physically weaker. Fight someone your own strength."
(it's a prohibition of violence to girls, couched in honorable terms. Not something like: "You toxic boy, stay away from them pure girls.")
To which the little boy I was replied: "What if she attacks me?" Father said: "don't fight back, just push back a bit, they don't hurt that much anyway..."