@hightor,
hightor wrote:
Quote:This is the very same game the left says all the time with their either or BS.
No, there isn't any "play book". A false dilemma can be intentional or accidental but it's not an ideologically-inspired tactic. Your criticism would be more effective if you exposed these sorts of informal fallacies as and where they appear rather than just making a generalized accusation and making up exaggerated examples. Point them out when you see them, no matter the political view of the author, and you'll be doing us all a service.
So, do you want taxes or do you want a government starved of revenue?
hightor appears not to recognize that the dilemma he continues to pose is obviously false. Clearly zero taxes of any kind would shutdown our government. However significantly reduced taxes will not. There are many
workable points between zero taxes and our present situation.
I recognize that the arguments on both sides of the matter were a bit overstated and that hightor's dilemma was in some sense a result in keeping with those overstatements. That's OK in itself.
The observable fact is that there is much waste, inefficiency and little real accountability in the various bureaucracies of our government: most are long overdue for significant reform. Simply the published facts about the multiple requests for added security at our consulate in Bengazi and the obvious lack of it during the ensuing attack, together with the fact that no one was ever held accountable tells us all we need to know. Worse, the refusal of the then head of the agency to accept any responsibility for the lack tells us a lot about some likely sources of this rot.
We are also now seeing some indirect consequences of former President Obama's frequent excursions beyond the law in advancing his programs. He appears to have left a legacy of such partisan action in many sections of the Federal bureaucracy. This is a potentially dangerous situation and it must be corrected if we are to retain the rule of law enacted by our elected representatives.
As a related matter the number of administratively enacted "regulations" in force today, at least in some areas where I have direct experience is truly breathtaking. Their number and reach has exploded in the last decade leaving a dense web off complexity that is understood by few of those subject to it and in some cases by even fewer of those selectively enforcing it. This is particularly evident in areas of employment, banking & finance, environmental standards, and as most of us experience, tax law. The result is often chaos, selective enforcement by ideologues in government, and widespread disregard for the rules both in government and among those subject to them. This does indeed inhibit our economic growth and thereby penalize everyone. Altogether a very bad situation that is getting worse every day, and one which also threatens our democracy.