@layman,
layman wrote:oralloy wrote:Civilians are a non-issue in any case. Hiroshima and Nagasaki were military targets.
Sorry, but you said this twice now, and it is misleading.
It's true that Truman announced it as "military base."
But history shows that the bombs were not aimed at military bases, even though there might have been some in the general vicinity.
Essentially, the bombs were dropped on "the city" with the purpose of causing as much demoralizing destruction as possible.
Yes, but Hiroshima had tens of thousands of Japanese soldiers in it, giving it the highest soldier/civilian ratio of any Japanese city (and more soldiers overall than any city other than Tokyo).
Hiroshima Castle was also the headquarters in charge of the defense of the southern half of Japan.
Nagasaki didn't have many soldiers, but it had huge weapons factories. One of those was the place that made the specially modified torpedoes that allowed Japan to attack the shallow waters of Pearl Harbor.