Quote:Randy Weber ✔ @TXRandy14
The CNN reporter who was disruptive to the press briefing, & disrespectful to Trump-should be fired & prohibited from any press briefings.
Add in Spicer's threat to remove Acosta from the news briefing if he continued to petition Trump to answer his question (Trump refused to take his question because he was with CNN which had carried a piece on the recent dossier).
Many American's don't appreciate how their political system differs from, say, England or Canada as regards traditions on news peoples' interactions with the governmental leader. Here, in what is terms the "scrum", reporters grill politicians including the leader informally during the day in hallways, staircases, etc. These can often be very challenging exchanges (and here in Canada, let's note, conservative politicians like Stockwell Day and Brian Mulroney have been much more reluctant to follow this tradition than have Liberal leaders).
But for the most part, in the US, Presidents engage the press in organized and more formal briefings, such as Trump did yesterday or as Obama has done. You might remember the interaction Bush 2 had with an Irish TV reporter who challenged him in a manner to which he was not accustomed and he wasn't happy with the informal and very challenging procedure or attitude
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-vefD3WSiis
What makes this a rather odd difference is that in the US, these traditions actually make America rather more imperial than parliamentary systems. The leader is treated more like a King or Queen than are parliamentary leaders. There can be, and often is, a greater expectation of deference towards a US leader.
And a high level of deference is what Webber and Spicer are demanding. That is, an imperial level of deference. Which underlines my point on this oddness - because it is happening in a republic.
The danger, of course, is that authoritarian figures can demand levels of deference which are totally inappropriate in a democracy. And they can act punitively (as Trump and Spicer did and as Webber demands) as a strategy to avoid valid challenge and to bully the press into obedience.
Some here might begin thinking of Joe Wilson's "You lie!" comment at an Obama SOTU speech and the outrage it caused. But that's a different venue entirely. The SOTU is one of the most formal governmental traditions for any president and Congress. What Wilson did there was unprecedented and violated the traditions of that formal structure. Interactions with the media in a press conference or a scrum are quite different and for good reasons.