@nimh,
I wrote
Quote:I don't see any good reason to presume that there is some change in culture caused by an increase in mental health issues. If that were the case, it would show up across society and would surely have caught the attention of mental health professionals and those responsible for monitoring health issues in the country
.
nimh wrote
Quote:I'm not sure this is just a matter of availability.. There seems to be something simultaneously more specific and broader going on.
Let's begin with a clarification. When I use the term "mental health" here, I mean to refer to structural anomalies or changes in the brain - schizophrenia, drug-induced psychosis, post-partum depression, etc, differentiated from emotional disturbances engendered in some social context - fear of a barbarian attack, a relationship failure, bullying, hopelessness from listening to country and western song lyrics day after day, etc.
If we broaden the term to include the latter category (and we commonly do) things get much foggier, particularly in trying to discern what's going on and the causes of it. For example, increased alcohol or drug use in some community where a traditional livelihood is lost (coal mining, Atlantic fishing, assembly line work. When I was speaking of "causality", that was what I meant. Obviously social conditions can and do foster emotional disturbances (this is probably the fundamental reason I subscribe to an ethics and politics of caring for others who are in trouble). Such social facts are in place along with availability. As the article I posted yesterday or day before noted, fentanyl out of China is an obvious causal factor.
This may all seem an unimportant distinction but I think it is because political strategies to deal with such phenomena will necessarily be different.