@reasoning logic,
Quote:Why do you claim him/her to be 41?
I was replying his/her absurd reasoning logic applied in his/her example or analogy, which was the Constitution made for 37 years old people, as an average age of Americans when the Constitution was signed.
Blickers wrote:
Quote: No. When the Constitution was adopted the life expectancy of Americans was 36.5 years.
His/her example can be debunked easily when the longevity of the signers of the Constitution where mostly twice the age given by the poster.
http://www.thomaslegion.net/listofsignersoftheunitedstatesconstitution.html
(Age added by me)
G. Washington-Presidt. and deputy from Virginia 68 yo* (*years old)
New Hampshire: John Langdon 78 yo, Nicholas Gilman 59 yo
Massachusetts: Nathaniel Gorham 58 yo, Rufus King 72 yo
Connecticut: Wm: Saml. Johnson 92 yo, Roger Sherman 72 yo
New York: Alexander Hamilton 47 yo
New Jersey: Wil: Livingston 67 yo, David Brearly 45 yo, Wm. Paterson 61 yo, Jona: Dayton 66 yo
Pennsylvania: B. Franklin 85 yo, Thomas Mifflin 56 yo, Robt. Morris 72 yo, and so forth.
This was their longevity, their ages at the time of signing the Constitution were different, of course, having Benjamin Franklin as the older one of them.
Just by obtaining an average longevity from the examples above, it was from 65 to 70 years of age the average of people of "high class" or "elite" or rich dudes.
Can't tell the average longevity of the population in general, but it might be very similar, because in those times almost everybody had to pickup dry branches of trees for making fire, run and catch the chicken for dinner, cut off wood, walk or prepare the horse, the food was for sure without additives and nothing genetically modified, the water pure but with bacteria, different air pollution, etc.
Perhaps, if you are interested in this topic of the average longevity, you might look for it by yourself online.
My point is about what was the example or analogy given, which is not valid because is based in the imagination of the poster, not so in a credible example to be used as comparison or analogy.