@tsarstepan,
Yeah, doesn’t need to be scary to be solid, but with the movie being hyped as horrifying, and Peele being hyped as a new genius at inducing suspense and fear, scary would be good.
They did a similar kind of buildup with M. Night Shamylan when he started. We can’t help but expect super creative blockbusters from Peele. I like the guy and love his humor (still watch Key and Peele), but this was just overhyped in my humble opinion.