@farmerman,
It does appear that Ryan may have been a bit cute with the facts, and led listeners to believe the plant was closed while Obama was president.
The fact that I haven't seen checked is whether or not Obama told would be voters that under his presidency it would stay open.
If he never said anything like this, than it would certainly seem that a serious break with the truth was committed.
The fact that George Bush's name can be evoked in the counter argument is substantively meaningless but convenient.
Ryan didn't consult me on his speech, but if he had I would have advised him to stick with undeniable facts, whether or not they had a Wisconsin connection. When the US taxpayers bailed out GM and the Obama Government took over it's management, thousands of people working for GM dealers lost their jobs. (Chances are pretty good that some lived in Wisconsin
This was probably necessary, but do we hear all the hacks droning on about Bain costing people jobs (and killing their wives) bemoan the cruel creative destruction of the Obama Administration?
We certainly don't hear them complaining about how it unilaterally rewrote bankruptcy law and first intimidated and then threw bond holders into the street in favor of their Union pals.
The point of the tale was that Obama made very grand promises to get elected; very few of which he kept.
No lie there.