@mysteryman,
mysteryman wrote:The supreme court said that bush won Florida, and that the recount attempt by Al Gore had to stop.
They were just acknowledging reality. The December 12 deadline had been reached, and Bush
had at that point won Florida.
Perhaps slightly more controversial that they halted the statewide recount on December 9, preventing it from being completed by December 12.
But there was a big appearance of impropriety on the part of the Florida Supreme Court, the way they kept allowing things to go just a little bit further every time it became apparent that Gore didn't quite win with the last step that had been taken. The US Supreme Court had clearly had enough of it.
And regardless, Bush still would have won that recount even if it had been allowed to proceed. So all in all I don't see how the ruling was all that big a deal.
Perhaps it would have looked better if the Supreme Court had let the statewide recount go up to December 12 before cutting them off, but it wouldn't have made any difference in the end.