@vikorr,
Quote:there are many views that Michael held that are not helpful to him
That's an understatement.
He's painted himself into a corner with his attitudes on many things--women, his ability to earn a decent living, his ability to change himself, etc., and he's not about to change any of those attitudes simply because he doesn't
want to. He's determined to remain a passive victim and wallow in self pity and his attitudes help to maintain that for him. He creates a self-fulfilling prophecy and then attributes his situation to some external "fate" when it's actually of his own doing.
Forgetting his carping about women for the moment, his attitudes toward earning money seem just as disconnected from reality. He's already said that his "chosen field", whatever that is, will never allow him to live without it being a continuous financial struggle. He already knows he will never be able to pay off his student loans, his current "fun job" doesn't even have medical insurance benefits, and he's about to be unemployed because he's going to move in with his sister in a few months. Probably the last thing he should be preoccupied with right now is a relationship that ended many months ago, and whether he'll get involved in another one. And a good part of what bothers him about himself is that he feels women see him as a financial loser, although he sees himself that way as well. But he doesn't seem to focus realistically on his long-term financial/career future, and his ability to alter that, and his need to improve that, any more than he's able to realistically focus on changing anything else about himself.
I think all his moaning and groaning about women is really the red herring in this thread. His problems with women, and his externalizing blame for those problems onto women, or the expectations of "society", is part and parcel of his general difficulties in living, and his tendencies to externalize blame in all areas where he has difficulty functioning. He views himself as deprived, disadvantaged, and inadequate, and helpless to alter those deficits, or to satisfy his needs. And as long as he rigidly clings to that sense of helplessness, and fails to make active changes, he continues to reinforce that helplessness and confirm it.
All of the excellent advice you have offered to him has all been in the direction of challenging that sense of helplessness, and urging him to take action and assume responsibility for
himself--in order to gain control over, and change, his attitudes, his emotional reactions, and his behavior, so he can obtain better outcomes and more satisfaction for himself--in all areas of his life. And he's rejected all of it.
He not only feels entitled to be a victim, something he justifies all over the place, he can't envision not being a victim. His over generalized thinking and his emotional level is very adolescent, like that of a young teen, except that adolescents of that age really have limited freedom and options, and they aren't yet emotionally mature, and that governs their attitudes and how they view things. Although MichaelJ is already an adult in his his early 30's, he continues to think and emotionally react like someone more than half his age. And that's why everyone here keeps telling him to grow up.
I don't doubt, at all, that some of this may stem from the fact that he lost both his parents when he was 12, and that he never finishing processing the resentment and rage and feelings of deprivation associated with that abandonment, and consequently he's still somewhat emotionally fixated at that developmental level. Those are issues he must deal with in therapy, but in his previous treatment, his therapists ran into the same sort of stone wall you have encountered with him, and eventually they gave up. He's not committed to wanting to change because he sees his problems as outside of himself, and beyond his control, rather than within himself, and very much under his control. He's the one who erects all those defensive barriers, and the self defeating attitudes, and he's the only one who can change them. When he was 12, much about his life may have been beyond his control, but, 20 years later, the same is not true, and he's still hanging onto the notion that he's a helpless victim.
Quote:he can choose to build who he is in the future - to recognize fears and turn them into strengths, to recognize weaknesses and practice strengthening those areas, to refine his strengths, to find passions, and to create a richness of character.
I agree with you completely. But nothing that you nor I have said, or could say, will convince MichaelJ of that. If he can't come to that realization for himself, he'll just go on maintaining his victim-hood.
He didn't come here looking for advice--he came here to prove himself right, to confirm his own hopeless outlook. He's already decided he's going to go on crapping up his own life.
Quote:I'm sure I'll continue to drink and eventually become an alcoholic, but eh ...I'm more outgoing when I drink anyway. And I'm sure I'll eventually kill myself sometime before I turn forty. I mean my dream is still an impossibility, and I am after all DEAD ON right about women...
.
This man's problems aren't "women". He simply can't function well as an adult in an adult world without hiding under a hat, or drinking to deal with his anxieties and emotions, or constructing all sorts of bullshit arguments to justify his own personal failures and his passivity in addressing them.
For him, marriage is a "dream" because he has no understanding of the realities and complexities of adult human relationships, or what people look for in such relationships, or the inevitable impermanence of most of those relationships. He's still like a high school adolescent bemoaning the fact that the jocks get all the girls, and seeing all those girls as pretty cheerleaders who wouldn't give him a second glance. Mainly he's bemoaning his problems getting laid, he's jealous of the guys who do, and he resents the fact he might have to work at making himself a more appealing partner for someone to become involved with.
His thinking is superficial and shallow. His coping mechanisms and social skills are inadequate, and he does nothing to improve them. His ability to recognize, and consider, and respond to, the needs of the other person in a relationship is poor. And his thinking about the subject of marriage and parenthood doesn't get beyond the "dream" stage of a fantasy about replacing the family he lost when he was 12. He's not looking at either marriage or parenthood through adult eyes, or with much appeciation of what those commitments are about.
So, let him go on drinking, and eventually bump himself off, if that's what he wants to do. It's his life. He has options, he knows he needs professional help, but he'd rather control his life in self destructive ways than put the effort into developing the strengths and capacities to help him function better in all areas of his life. He'd rather see himself as some sort of martyr, and blame it on being a male, to give his victim-hood the false aura of heroic stature, than see that he is the one victimizing himself.
If MichaelJ's life has no meaning for him it's because he chooses to give it no meaning--it has nothing to do with whether "dreams are unattainable". He said he found A2K because he Googled, "Life is a joke". If he feels his life is a joke, and he has no more regard for himself than that, and he'd rather wallow in self pity and drown his sorrows in booze than actually try to improve things for himself, that's his choice too.
I'm rather tired of indulging his pity party, which is how he is using this thread. You and I seem to be giving more time and effort to considering his problems than he bothers to do. If he wants to go on seeing himself as a helpless victim, that's fine with me. It's his life and his choice.