52
   

Question to those who do or do not doubt Christianity

 
 
reasoning logic
 
  2  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 05:57 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
Quote:

What would you label giving me your time to explain how you feel there is No such existence of a God, on these message forums?


I personally label this psychology, sociology, neuroscience and so forth. My main interest is human behavior and the causes of beliefs. You could label this a waste of time because there is a lot of time wasted when discussing these issues with believers but this is how I learn.

When I say believers I am not talking about religion only.

You bring up how there are videos of atheist and Christians doing things that are evil.
I personally think we should call these acts of evil what they are. evil, immoral, harmful, destructive and so on.

I can not understand how people can be so intelligent and do such evil acts. I should not say I don't understand them completely because I have studied these behaviors for many hours so I do have some understanding of what is going on.
Why do you believe the bible to be the word of God? Do you not see the primitive behavior that was taught in the bible? Do you not see the violence?
History of religion, anthropology and other studies can add so much more to our understanding of religion.
0 Replies
 
BillRM
 
  1  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 08:52 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
My religion friend you came into the public square to promote your beliefs and I been addressing your religion on the grounds first that it insult the intelligent of the average 10 years old that had not had it drill into him or her before he or she could used reason to filter it out.

Second to me those beliefs had proven to be far more harmful then not over the two thousands years that your cult had been around.

Whole peoples men, women and children had been wiped off the face of the earth over the issue of how must Jesus was a man and how must he was a god for example.

As late as Newtons times he needed to keep secret his opinions of the godhood of Jesus in order not to be punish or even torture to death.

From before Newton days to current times the good people of the bible are fighting against the advancement of science to the best of their abilities.

Chights47
 
  2  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 11:22 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
To me there is plenty of evidence, observe 20 people doing a Good act, go up to them and ask them pardon me by if you don't mind me asking what religion/lack of religion are you, and the odds are 5 of them will be Christ followers....It terms of evidence of a God being Good or trustworthy, You have 2 perfect examples right in your life that you know of, Your fiance, and myself...Do you believe we are being lead astray by something that "compels" us to do good in his name???
Statistically it should actually be 4 out of 5 (or more) of those 20 people do to the sheer number of Christians in the country. This country is about 80%-85% Christian while being about 90% theistic? It's also why more than 3/4 people in the prison population are Christian. As far as your examples of your God being good, I unfortunately cannot count you solely because I do not know really anything about you, and that which I do know, I can't verify. In regards to my fiance, the only reason I know her is due to a horrible relationship in which she was in previously which has lead to numerous relationship problems between us (none of which your God has helped with). There was also a break in our relationship (her idea do to previous relationship) in which we dated other people, and during that time I had the worst experience with another woman (total psycho). Also due to this extended break, it pushed back our engagement, which pushed back our marriage, which may lead us to not having biological children due to a certain condition in which she now has...So much for your God eh?

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
Everyone is Ignorant at times, faith itself is not about gullibility, it is probably the single hardest thing on the face of the planet to accept and embrace. If it was about Gullibility, than EVERYONE would in fact be doing it, with perfection, and with the simplest of ease....it's not about brainwashing at all, (least not for the faithful ones) My message on coming here, is not to force nor impose you to do or not to do, and your saved or screwed, but rather to enhance your inhibitions as to your beliefs/lack of beliefs, and if it isn't that way, then why do you say after reading my posts, with which I depict a very merciful God indeed...You go farther toward Atheism. So in NO way, am I here to brainwash, and your freely doing as you please...If it was brainwashing, then you would see people converted left and right on there forums as "proof".

Faith is about gullibility, a synonym of gullible is actually blind faith which is what religion is about. Anything about beyond blind faith would require proof and as you said, your God cannot prove himself with completely destroying free-will (or so you claimed in the past). I do agree that blind faith is hard because it requires you to not question what is taught while it's in our nature to question things and to search for answers. Even though it is about gullibility, everyone isn't a part of it because some people are able to ask the right questions and search for the honest answers without an agenda to try and prove their current conclusions/beliefs right. Science is about making conclusions from facts and evidence while religion is about making facts and evidence from conclusions. It is also about brainwashing, childhood indoctrination IS brainwashing. When a child is very young they learn things at extraordinary rates but do not yet have the ability to discern what is true from what is false. Many religions pick up on this and brainwash children into dogmatically believing in a religion in which they pretty much have no choice otherwise. If you would like I can bring up video's showing this?

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
I can in fact make the SAME exact argument about Atheism, You do realize this right? Like I said, It all depends on the person, people involved. Not the focal point of the Belief system in place. I think you need to venture into understanding the Christian person more, rather than viewing the person, with the belief in your mind. Looking at them from the outside...and likewise it would not be a bad Idea. If I got to know and understand "real Pragmatic Atheists, and understood them as a person more....Because to you, it would be progressing Humanity, and for me, and would be loving ALL my brother and sister equally, and continuing to accept them and love them regardless of their belief/view on God...That is what Jesus Christ is ALL about...
You actually can't make the same argument. I was referring solely to the belief in a personal deity, since Atheism does not believe in a deity, you cannot make that argument. It's not all about the person/people involved unless you're tring to say that your God is meaningless in this? Since your god doesn't do anything, never has, and never will, theirs no point in praying to him or worshipping him. As Epicurus once said:
“Is God willing to prevent evil, but not able?
Then he is not omnipotent.
Is he able, but not willing?
Then he is malevolent.
Is he both able and willing?
Then whence cometh evil?
Is he neither able nor willing?
Then why call him God?”

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
The act of accepting Jesus, and doing nothing, with conjunction to living a life according to Christ? I agree to a point, But if they truly are very bad sinners, and can't right their wrongs, or don't even have the will power to change. Then what should they do? At least with a God, he gives them a way out in life eternal, whether the simplest of simple in Heaven, it does not matter anymore. (If the Bible is correct, and a Heaven exists...remember, Some people are just not mentally as strong as you and I are in this world, and others on here...SO they Should just suffer, and suck at everything they do, with only death their comfort? I will gladly accept a God exists to enlighten their new beginning forever more then. (if that's your view)...
If eternal life doesn't exist then all you're doing is lying to the person, what good does lying do? In over 2000 years not a single theist has ever been able to prove the existence of anything regarding any sort of after life or a heaven or hell. The closest that we've ever gotten are claims in which are explained as mere delusions. If these visions were actually real (such as the ones you've supposedly had) wouldn't that be proof (to you at least) which would destroy your free-will? Since you've supposedly seen heaven and hell doesn't that leave you with no choice but to accept your God?

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
There will always be horrible and immoral lessons in everything, Including Atheism...So what is the point then, to dismiss everything all together??
What horrible immoral lessons are in atheism? If they are valid concerns in which I hold I can guarantee that will no longer be there, they will either be replaced or discarded, that is what atheism is about (at least to me). It's about what is doing what is best and most effective to progress humanity and doing that which promotes happiness, wellbeing and health, and minimizing unnecessary harm and suffering.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
Good question, to the fullest, and not to bring you down. But I am not a Pessimist, but a realist...and the simple fact is that, those things you listed above MAY NEVER HAPPEN to the fullest
It's funny how if you don't say you're a realist, people always assume you're a pessimist (I'm a realist as well). If your God is as powerful as you say then, why can't he do this? Why does he just leave the world in such turmoil? Why has he let things spin so far out of control? Why do he allow such hate and filth be spoken and done in his name when in the days of the bible he would have struck them down? Why does he allow his teachings to be manipulated and twisted into bigotry, hatred, and lies? Why does he allow any of this to happen at all, why is humanity left to suffer that way that it does and why does your God allow us to continue down this path of destruction?

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
If it in fact happens that way, none the less the point with which someone would have to do, reach or cross to be at that point..."from my understandings" they truly deserve to be there...But none the less, you may luck out and God may grant purgatory, or no afterlife whatsoever to appease all...Just many other possibilities...It isn't black and white like you "think it is" I have said and ill say many more times on here...
There is nothing in which anyone could ever do in any amount of time that would be deserving of such a fate, much less those in which you would call your children. The "just and benevolent" God in which you speak of would know that. As far as purgatory or the end of existence, where do you get this from? These are the rationalizations that I'm talking about! There is no meantion of any of this in the supposed word of your God. You disagree with the one life and your done plan in which is stated in the bible which is completely fucked up (pardon the language). So what you do is concoct these rationalization which aren't meantioned anywhere to try and make sense of this so that you can continue down this path of delusions! There's no real evidence to support a heaven and hell and much less for the rationalizations in which you giving it.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
Just MORE plausibility, Or Fire-Power, that an afterlife, would NOT be such a Bad thing after all...considering A LOT more than not will be In Heaven, apposed to Hell...
Why does their need to be an after-life at all, why can't we all just be born in heaven without having to deal with life on earth? Why must people go through all of this hatred and oppression and all the horrors that this world has to offer if pretty much everyone is going to end up in heaven anyway?
Chights47
 
  2  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 11:33 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
It would be FLAT out Ridiculous to waste my time to post links of videos of Atheists who practice pure abominations and wickedness, in conjunction to the Atheists on here, who actually "show" they value and are "trying to" progress humanity
Just so you know, the difference between the immoral actions of theists verse those of atheists is that Atheism doesn't teach or tell people to do those horrible acts. Religion teaches many things but included in those things are great hate, bigotry, and oppression and no one has had enough common sense or fortitude to remove it. Thus with it still being there in it's teachings, it is still flawed and will forever remain as such.
Chights47
 
  2  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 11:35 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
Bill I mean this in the MOST beneficial way for everyone who has to read you audacity and utter gual you post! When you are mature enough to stand down from your soap box, and stop believing "your opinions" are ALWAYS EXACTLY RIGHT and NEVER WRONG, than I, as well as a lot of others on here will take you SERIOUSLY! And Will GLADLY TALK WITH YOU!! Once you REALIZE your being utterly immature to say the least, people will actually except your views and positions WILLINGLY!!!

I wish you the best of luck with your life, and wish no harm for you in your life...but in All honesty, it would be the BEST THING FOR YOUR SAKE, to stop posting on these threads, UNLESS your attitude and opinions change dramitically!!

I have NOTHING more to say...Good luck bro, with the way you act and live. Your probably going to need all the luck you can get. Otherwise someone out there is probably going to kick the living **** out of you one day if not kill you for your tongue...have a nice life Bill....
Very Happy thumbs up because this made me laugh!
izzythepush
 
  2  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 11:51 am
@Chights47,
Me too.
0 Replies
 
reasoning logic
 
  1  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 11:58 am
@Chights47,
You have made some very good points. It seems that a lot can be learned from you.
0 Replies
 
BillRM
 
  3  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 01:21 pm
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
Below is a message that seems almost aim at you be the third president of the US Thomas Jefferson.


Shake off all the fears of servile prejudices, under which weak minds are servilely crouched. Fix reason firmly in her seat, and call on her tribunal for every fact, every opinion. Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason than that of blindfolded fear.

north
 
  2  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 04:14 pm
between Chights47 and BillRM

we have good thinking happening here

it is refreashing to say the least
Chights47
 
  1  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 04:24 pm
Thanks for the compliments guys, I'm really not as smart as you seem to think but thanks none the less!
0 Replies
 
reasoning logic
 
  1  
Reply Sun 11 Dec, 2011 04:26 pm
@BillRM,
Thomas Jefferson did have a good point. Great quote.
0 Replies
 
XXSpadeMasterXX
 
  2  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 12:44 am
@Chights47,
Quote:
Statistically it should actually be 4 out of 5 (or more) of those 20 people do to the sheer number of Christians in the country. This country is about 80%-85% Christian while being about 90% theistic? It's also why more than 3/4 people in the prison population are Christian. As far as your examples of your God being good, I unfortunately cannot count you solely because I do not know really anything about you, and that which I do know, I can't verify. In regards to my fiance, the only reason I know her is due to a horrible relationship in which she was in previously which has lead to numerous relationship problems between us (none of which your God has helped with). There was also a break in our relationship (her idea do to previous relationship) in which we dated other people, and during that time I had the worst experience with another woman (total psycho). Also due to this extended break, it pushed back our engagement, which pushed back our marriage, which may lead us to not having biological children due to a certain condition in which she now has...So much for your God eh?

But why would you BLAME God? Do you think God is leading her astray? Or do you believe, that it was in your life mission to prove you two belong together by "testing it" and that your fiance's bad other partner, and this psycho you dated are to blame, not God...It may have been a test of your fiance's "faith". As far as you maybe not having children, that's tough, but to me, somethings are not meant to be, my Aunt can't have children, and she FULLY embraces Christ, but does not blame Christ, for not being able to have children, instead she is a Godmother of about 4 in my family, and in turn IS being a MOTHER....When one door closes another one opens!

Quote:
Faith is about gullibility, a synonym of gullible is actually blind faith which is what religion is about. Anything about beyond blind faith would require proof and as you said, your God cannot prove himself with completely destroying free-will (or so you claimed in the past). I do agree that blind faith is hard because it requires you to not question what is taught while it's in our nature to question things and to search for answers. Even though it is about gullibility, everyone isn't a part of it because some people are able to ask the right questions and search for the honest answers without an agenda to try and prove their current conclusions/beliefs right. Science is about making conclusions from facts and evidence while religion is about making facts and evidence from conclusions. It is also about brainwashing, childhood indoctrination IS brainwashing. When a child is very young they learn things at extraordinary rates but do not yet have the ability to discern what is true from what is false. Many religions pick up on this and brainwash children into dogmatically believing in a religion in which they pretty much have no choice otherwise. If you would like I can bring up video's showing this?

And I can bet dollars to donuts. the same exact thing is Happening with Atheists, who by their actions and "anti-God" beliefs who indoctrunate Children to Jade God, would you NOT agree, I know a few who have!

Quote:
You actually can't make the same argument. I was referring solely to the belief in a personal deity, since Atheism does not believe in a deity, you cannot make that argument. It's not all about the person/people involved unless you're tring to say that your God is meaningless in this? Since your god doesn't do anything, never has, and never will, theirs no point in praying to him or worshipping him.

The belief in a deity is at best (in my opinion) selfish and at worst destructive and hateful.

I can in fact make the SAME exact argument about Atheism, You do realize this right?

I can make the same argument because if your an Atheist, and are "not for" progressing Humanity, than it could very easily be viewed as selfish...and at worst, destructive, and to the point of hate...and if your particular Views on God are wrong, you could potentially be leading millions astray....And I will explain again, God is Leading me toward the path of light, So I can't "prove it" to you, but either you accept what I am saying and or not, and "understand" that to many there is in fact REASONS to Pray, and or worship...if that light from God, gets them to act and do "responsible, and acts of progressing humanity" then again would you call it pointless to embrace this light??

Quote:
If eternal life doesn't exist then all you're doing is lying to the person, what good does lying do? In over 2000 years not a single theist has ever been able to prove the existence of anything regarding any sort of after life or a heaven or hell. The closest that we've ever gotten are claims in which are explained as mere delusions. If these visions were actually real (such as the ones you've supposedly had) wouldn't that be proof (to you at least) which would destroy your free-will? Since you've supposedly seen heaven and hell doesn't that leave you with no choice but to accept your God?

Nothing, but if Eternal life, does, than what good does it to to Deny, that it does, on the basis that there is "no proof" when we all know and understand the basis of finding this God, afterlife, is based about NOT questioning it , them...So if you question to the point of disbelief, why would you EVER believe you would find "it" your way??

And if Life eternal does exist, then your lying to people by saying to them it doesn't on the basis that you know whats better for others than they do, because Atheism works for you, Doesn't that show selfishness to you, to a certain degree, rather than ridding the world of useless, outdated, things etc??? It is proof to me, but that does not mean I am forced to accept God, and by the actions of sins I go against God many times, and use my free will...I could denounce God, and be a false prophet at anytime, and reject everything he says to me, and I see my life will be far worse than it is, apposed to better...and reliable proof, of people with near death experiences and my visions and dreams, can never be discredited. Just because you never incur something does not mean that something else hasn't, and it doesn't exist....or are delusions...

Quote:
What horrible immoral lessons are in atheism? If they are valid concerns in which I hold I can guarantee that will no longer be there, they will either be replaced or discarded, that is what atheism is about (at least to me). It's about what is doing what is best and most effective to progress humanity and doing that which promotes happiness, wellbeing and health, and minimizing unnecessary harm and suffering.

Denial, outside the circle of ones understandings of Self-Honesty, and Self-Awareness...If your telling me in that "progressing Humanity" that by the very nature, you know and understand what it better for another human being in conjunction to their beliefs in positive manner in a God, than that is a horrible immoral lesson indeed, and I doubt that Atheists will EVER stop doing this, and discard these actions....

Quote:
It's funny how if you don't say you're a realist, people always assume you're a pessimist (I'm a realist as well). If your God is as powerful as you say then, why can't he do this? Why does he just leave the world in such turmoil? Why has he let things spin so far out of control? Why do he allow such hate and filth be spoken and done in his name when in the days of the bible he would have struck them down? Why does he allow his teachings to be manipulated and twisted into bigotry, hatred, and lies? Why does he allow any of this to happen at all, why is humanity left to suffer that way that it does and why does your God allow us to continue down this path of destruction?

Simple answer, for the basis of "free will" would you want to be struck down and taken away, do to lack of faith? and what kind of God would he be in making us exceedingly smart, so that we have free will, and then decide to force us to follow and obey him? it destroys the notion of a pieceful, merciful God...and that were in fact the greatest of all creations...

Quote:
There is nothing in which anyone could ever do in any amount of time that would be deserving of such a fate, much less those in which you would call your children. The "just and benevolent" God in which you speak of would know that. As far as purgatory or the end of existence, where do you get this from? These are the rationalizations that I'm talking about! There is no meantion of any of this in the supposed word of your God. You disagree with the one life and your done plan in which is stated in the bible which is completely fucked up (pardon the language). So what you do is concoct these rationalization which aren't meantioned anywhere to try and make sense of this so that you can continue down this path of delusions! There's no real evidence to support a heaven and hell and much less for the rationalizations in which you giving it.

there in fact is again read up on the story of St. Catherine of Siena, and read about her brother choosing to go to Hell, and read about how she went to purgatory to "free souls" and you will see how God has many different plans and agendas than a black and white ending that people presume in the Bible, it also says in the Bible, that not everything God says or does is in there, for it would be impossible to list them all! and that the very object of the Bible is to use it as a guide, and become of prudent, so that you can make good healthy choices in all instances...

Quote:
Why does their need to be an after-life at all, why can't we all just be born in heaven without having to deal with life on earth? Why must people go through all of this hatred and oppression and all the horrors that this world has to offer if pretty much everyone is going to end up in heaven anyway?

How then would we be God's GREATEST creation then? without being tested here??



XXSpadeMasterXX
 
  2  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 12:52 am
@north,
Quote:
between Chights47 and BillRM

we have good thinking happening here

it is refreshing to say the least

it is in fact not good thinking in terms of Bill, because in his mention of how God of the Old, killed people in destroying the world, he "chooses" to "leave out" the Part of the God of the New convenant, Jesus, and what he said and did, and Giving us piece and mercy, and depicts, Love, acceptance, Piece, Mercy etc....

I on the other hand will say that I agree that Chights, views are at least of meaning and refreshing....as well as many other Atheists on here...

When Bill chooses to listen rather than open his mouth all the time, I may find it acceptable to say his views are refreshing....
0 Replies
 
XXSpadeMasterXX
 
  2  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 01:20 am
Izzythepush, why is your name that?? as a matter of fact, if you guys are willing to explain, I am interested in knowing why you guys chose those specif screen names??
XXSpadeMasterXX
 
  2  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 01:24 am
@BillRM,

Quote:
Shake off all the fears of servile prejudices, under which weak minds are servilely crouched. Fix reason firmly in her seat, and call on her tribunal for every fact, every opinion. Question with boldness even the existence of a God; because, if there be one, he must more approve of the homage of reason than that of blindfolded fear.

And who says, that I don't question him? and validate the Homage of reason, apposed to blindfolded fear? Who says I validate the existence of God, based on blindfolded fear? (if your willing to ask) (then be willing to accept my views and opinions, and don't dismiss them)
reasoning logic
 
  2  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 02:02 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
Quote:
And who says, that I don't question him? and validate the Homage of reason, apposed to blindfolded fear? Who says I validate the existence of God, based on blindfolded fear? (if your willing to ask) (then be willing to accept my views and opinions, and don't dismiss them)


Great questions. What are your answers to these questions? If your answer is that you do question your God and your beliefs, is it possible to do it honestly without having a little understanding about the history of religion, psychology and anthropology?
When I mention these subjects I not suggesting that you get a degree in them but to simply study them in relation to religion and other beliefs.
0 Replies
 
BillRM
 
  1  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 02:23 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
Quote:
And who says, that I don't question him? and validate the Homage of reason, apposed to blindfolded fear? Who says I validate the existence of God, based on blindfolded fear? (if your willing to ask) (th be willing to accept my views and opinions, and don't dismiss them)


By your own statements on this thread as a matter of fact where faith if the only fall back position you had come up with.

In any case, there is no logic or reason that support the idea of any given personal god from Zeus to the Christians three in one god.

It all come down to faith and wishful thinkings not logic or commonsense.

To sum up there is not a bit more reason to think that there is a three in one god of the Christian type then any of the uncounted numbers of gods and goddesses the human race had come up with in our history.

It all come down to something completely apart from logic and reason with your reason only coming into the matter to find an excuse to why your three in one god does not communicate in a direct and open manner with the human race.

Here is another quote from President Jefferson........

And the day will come, when the mystical generation of Jesus, by the Supreme Being as His Father, in the womb of a virgin, will be classed with the fable of the generation of Minerva, in the brain of Jupiter.


0 Replies
 
izzythepush
 
  1  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 02:41 am
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:

Izzythepush, why is your name that?? as a matter of fact, if you guys are willing to explain, I am interested in knowing why you guys chose those specif screen names??


Quote:
Nova Express is a social commentary on human and machine control of life. The Nova Mob—Sammy the Butcher, Izzy the Push, The Subliminal Kid, and others—are viruses, "defined as the three-dimensional coordinate point of a controller." "which invade the human body and in the process produce language." These Nova Criminals represent society, culture, and government, and have taken control. Inspector Lee and the rest of the Nova Police are left fighting for the rest of humanity in the power struggle.


http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nova_Express

0 Replies
 
Chights47
 
  2  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 03:29 pm
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
But why would you BLAME God? Do you think God is leading her astray? Or do you believe, that it was in your life mission to prove you two belong together by "testing it" and that your fiance's bad other partner, and this psycho you dated are to blame, not God...It may have been a test of your fiance's "faith". As far as you maybe not having children, that's tough, but to me, somethings are not meant to be, my Aunt can't have children, and she FULLY embraces Christ, but does not blame Christ, for not being able to have children, instead she is a Godmother of about 4 in my family, and in turn IS being a MOTHER....When one door closes another one opens!
I don't blame your God anymore than I blame Zeus or Thor, or Wotan, or any of the other thousands of gods that I don't believe exists. I don't think that your God is leading anyone anywhere because I think he/she/it is only a figment of people's imaginations. She also didn't start really getting into Christianity until I started being more open about my atheism which is causing yet another rift between us and has lead to arguments about how we would raise our children. I believe secular until they are the age of reason, she believes to raise a child Christian and then given the "choice" after they've been brainwashed. She was raised Catholic so she's into the whole brainwashing thing. I also don't believe that things are meant to be, nor do I believe in fate or any kind of divine plan. The only reason people believe this is because there are so many different factors that are out of control that most people don't realize or understand. People then just attribute what happens to and around them to some supernatural cause.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
And I can bet dollars to donuts. the same exact thing is Happening with Atheists, who by their actions and "anti-God" beliefs who indoctrunate Children to Jade God, would you NOT agree, I know a few who have!
I wouldn't doubt that it might occasionally happen but are you (no offense) so ignorant of atheism that you think this is how our philosophy works? I would find this very hard to believe unless you're suggesting that either Christian families are brainwashing their children to hate the religion that they believe (among others) or that atheists are reproducing like rabbits (do to the fast increase in those that claim to be atheist). Ignorance, gullibility, and brainwashing are at the very core of religion while in atheism it may occasionally scrape the outer surface but it is definitely not what atheism is about. To me and many others, atheism is about free thought, it's about using reason, logic, and common sense to determine for yourself what shall be deemed right and wrong. It's not about just accepting the views of someone else just because they say they're right.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
I can make the same argument because if your an Atheist, and are "not for" progressing Humanity, than it could very easily be viewed as selfish...and at worst, destructive, and to the point of hate...and if your particular Views on God are wrong, you could potentially be leading millions astray....And I will explain again, God is Leading me toward the path of light, So I can't "prove it" to you, but either you accept what I am saying and or not, and "understand" that to many there is in fact REASONS to Pray, and or worship...if that light from God, gets them to act and do "responsible, and acts of progressing humanity" then again would you call it pointless to embrace this light??
You still don't understand, you are still making an argument against the philosophies and people. I'm making the argument solely against the belief in a deity, since atheism does not have that, you cannot make an argument against it. Why would it matter if I supposedly lead millions astray? According to you pretty much everyone goes to heaven (if any are sent to hell at all that is) so I don't see how that is really an issue, unless we only have this one life and our acceptance into heaven is based solely on blind faith like it clearly states in the bible? If we're supposedly both going down "paths of light" then what does is matter what we believe in since this supposedly is irrelevant now? If something is beneficial then it is never pointless, nor did I ever claim as such. I'm only stating that so much more could be done that what currently is being done. I think I may have used this example a while ago but I'll state it again. Imagine how great the world would be if all the time spent in devotion to a god was instead spent in devotion to progressing and aiding humanity and the world? That would literally be BILLIONS of hours EVERY WEEK doing something that's ACTUALLY productive! Not only would the people who do good be more productive in this, but all the people who do horrible things would instead do good! This would flip the world and all the species on it in a 180 and make this a pretty sweet place to live in almost no time! So just imagine how the world is now, and how much better it could be.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
Nothing, but if Eternal life, does, than what good does it to to Deny, that it does, on the basis that there is "no proof" when we all know and understand the basis of finding this God, afterlife, is based about NOT questioning it , them...So if you question to the point of disbelief, why would you EVER believe you would find "it" your way??

And if Life eternal does exist, then your lying to people by saying to them it doesn't on the basis that you know whats better for others than they do, because Atheism works for you, Doesn't that show selfishness to you, to a certain degree, rather than ridding the world of useless, outdated, things etc??? It is proof to me, but that does not mean I am forced to accept God, and by the actions of sins I go against God many times, and use my free will...I could denounce God, and be a false prophet at anytime, and reject everything he says to me, and I see my life will be far worse than it is, apposed to better...and reliable proof, of people with near death experiences and my visions and dreams, can never be discredited. Just because you never incur something does not mean that something else hasn't, and it doesn't exist....or are delusions...
First off, I don't question based on conclusions. I develop conclusions based on the evidence that I find (or don't find) based on the indifferent questions I ask in attempt to discern what is true from what is false. This is what it means to be rational and to be a "free thinker". Accepting something without questioning it is a test of gullibility which is the blind faith in which you hold so dear. I'm not specifically claiming that there is no afterlife. I'm stating that the claim has no credibility or evidence what-so-ever, they are very similar but not one in the same. To deny an after life is to state that you are 100% sure there is no after life. I'm merely saying that the possibility of it's non-existence is so astronomically high that it almost amounts to the same thing. Why would your life automatically get worse without your God? Why can't you simply live the same life that you're living now just without him. Why can't you just do the same good deeds, be just as loving and caring, etc? My life actually improved significantly once I started living without the thoughts of Gods for I was in control and I lead my life the way that I wanted to so that I might do the most good. I'm also not saying that people have to accept the same exact things as I do or nything like that. Atheism (to me at least) is about what works best and is most effective, and what works best and is most effective for me may not be the same as for you. God's, however, do not help anyone in anyway thus are pointless to spend time on. Pray doesn't work in any sense except in tautology. Your God supposedly answers prayers in a "yes", "no", or "wait" fashion, what people don't seem to realize is that I could say the same thing about my ass! If you pray to my ass it will answer your prayers in a "yes", "no", or "wait" fashion...and of course it will...supposedly.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
Denial, outside the circle of ones understandings of Self-Honesty, and Self-Awareness...If your telling me in that "progressing Humanity" that by the very nature, you know and understand what it better for another human being in conjunction to their beliefs in positive manner in a God, than that is a horrible immoral lesson indeed, and I doubt that Atheists will EVER stop doing this, and discard these actions....
I may not know what's better but I can see what is worse and I can suggest ways in which to improve a situation. How does your "personal relationship" with the magical daddy in the sky help anyone? He sure isn't helping anything down here, so really all he is is an empty void that sucks up time in which could be spent doing something positive for someone else...and that's on the good side. Religion is the cause of the fighting in Israel, religion is the cause of so much suffering in the horn of Africa, and the list goes on. Yes, religion can also do good things as well but why must it come with this catch all for a God that doesn't do anything?

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
Simple answer, for the basis of "free will" would you want to be struck down and taken away, do to lack of faith? and what kind of God would he be in making us exceedingly smart, so that we have free will, and then decide to force us to follow and obey him? it destroys the notion of a pieceful, merciful God...and that were in fact the greatest of all creations...
Wouldn't I be struck down and taken away due to lack of faith anyway? Wht kind of God would he be to make us some of us so exceedingly smart that we realize that the natural world do not represent the claims that are in the bible? If your God really is the creator of the universe, then why would make all of these "false" evidences which lead to the rational conclusions that he does not exist? Why can't he reveal himself and show himself to the world in a wy that no one would doubt him? If he did, how would that destroy free will? Would I still not have the choice to not follow him and to continue on my own way? Free will is about choice, we always have a choice even if all other options seem so far fetched and undesirable, they still remain an option. Let's say that your God is as perfect as you claim, if he were to reveal himself than only a fool would not chose to follow him...does that mean that the choice does not still remain? The answer is no, the choice does still remain and we retain our free will but the world ends up being much better place under the guidance of your God rather than the "chaos" in which is upon us now.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
there in fact is again read up on the story of St. Catherine of Siena, and read about her brother choosing to go to Hell, and read about how she went to purgatory to "free souls" and you will see how God has many different plans and agendas than a black and white ending that people presume in the Bible, it also says in the Bible, that not everything God says or does is in there, for it would be impossible to list them all! and that the very object of the Bible is to use it as a guide, and become of prudent, so that you can make good healthy choices in all instances...
After reading a little back story on her it has lead me to even more questions in which I won't get into. I don't know for certain if the positions that I'll discuss are ones that you hold and regardless of whether you do our not, any flaw that I do find in them are sure to come along with some new on the spot rationalization.

XXSpadeMasterXX wrote:
How then would we be God's GREATEST creation then? without being tested here??
What's the point in being tested here if your God already knows how we're going to end up anyway? Why do we have to be tested here of all places? Why can't we test ourselves throughout all eternity in heaven in whatever we choose or whatever your God wants? Why do we need to prove ourselves as the greatest "creation" anyway? Why can't we just have the title because your God's given to us? I honestly don't really see how we can be called the "greatest species" except by your God's word alone. We are single handedly destroying the world faster than it can fix itself. We destroy entire species just for personal gain, and many other horrible things. Because of this I would actually call us the worst species on earth since this worlds survival is in our hands and right now it's headed right down the tubes.

Chights47
 
  1  
Reply Mon 12 Dec, 2011 03:30 pm
@XXSpadeMasterXX,
My Screen name is a partial mixture of my first and last name and the number is my lucky number.
0 Replies
 
 

Related Topics

Atheism - Discussion by littlek
The tolerant atheist - Discussion by Tuna
Another day when there is no God - Discussion by edgarblythe
church of atheism - Discussion by daredevil
Can An Atheist Have A Soul? - Discussion by spiritual anrkst
THE MAGIC BUS COMES TO CANADA - Discussion by Setanta
 
Copyright © 2025 MadLab, LLC :: Terms of Service :: Privacy Policy :: Page generated in 0.06 seconds on 05/05/2025 at 09:07:14