@Lash,
Lash wrote:
Quote:Really; and you think the Vietnamese could ever have killed and maimed so many of us if we had not given them the opportunity??? What of the North Koreans???
You said the "Communists" couldn't have - now, you've amended to "Vietnamese." Quite a difference.
Quote:We get some damned theory in our heads about dominoes and apply it to world politics and economics... What is the cost;
What cost is the domino theory? You seem to be devolving into some word salad, Fido. Seems like an emotional rant. Gather your thoughts and make them coherent, please.
Quote:They say: Communism is good in theory but terrible in reality.... Since all people every where have survived some form of communism and we have all come out of it, the opposite must be true, that is is terrible in theory, because it succeeded well in reality; but recreated out of an ideal, it has been a failure, and still as a failure, in many respects successful...
Who is "they"? Again, I think you are in a really small group of people who think Communism "succeeded well in reality"... Ask a Russian or a former resident of the USSR what they think of the brand of Communism they lived under. I have. Those of us who thought it was a living hell were correct. I haven't had one person to say differently. Something happens to the human spirit when you are stripped of personal rights. I feel comfortable guessing that the vast majority of people would choose the strictures of Capitalism to those of Communism. Neither is perfect - but one is a great deal better than the other, imo.
I don't mind that you don't agree.
You are a perfect example of how people use their labels to objectify others, dehumanize them, and justify doing violence to them all through their choice of words...
There were some communists in Vietnam, but Ho Chi Minh for an example was smart enough to realize that it was just a form of relationship, and not nearly so strong a relationship as a shared culture and nationality... He also saw the injury hard core communist from China did to Vietnam, and their economy after the French were driven out... Now, I want you to look at the fact... Ho and the Vietnamese made their case for independence at the Versailles peace conference, and no less than the Arabs for that matter; and we stood back and watched... Ho also spent nearly an entire lifetime on the run, much of it is England and France, the very countries that would have killed him if they could have caught him... It is safe to say, that just as in the Art of War, That he understood us far better than we understood him... And, He had the advantage of understanding his own people, their needs, and their determination for freedom...
Part of the problem with your thinking is that you confuse the issues... And our government does no less; only they do so on purpose... We hated the Taliban, but attacked Afghanistan... We hated Saddam, but attacked Iraq... And while we use the excuse of how many of his own he killed; we killed far more of his people than he did... We did the same after WWI with the Germans, and while I could admit that the German army was guilty of many outrages, injustices, and crimes against the civilian populations they controlled, they also lied to their own people, and bled their whole people when the people were long powerless to control their leaders, or the army... And to hold the whole people responsible, and to not force the army to take responsibility and surrender and disbane doomed the civil government of Weimar...
But if the shoe were on the other foot, how would you like it if our president commited international crimes, and others held this whole people responsible??? Isn't that what 911 was about??? Isn't that why we took such offense at the enemies of America, and did nothing to hold the president who let it happen responsible??? We were sleep walking, and instead of blaming the president we took it out on a lot of innocent people who were as powerless in their own lives as we are in ours...And think of the cost, of the destruction of our economy trying to pretend we are something we are not on borrowed money... We have lost far more lives in having our revenge than the attack cost us in people, and we have taken far more lives than we have lost for revenge... So what you say, that the Vietnamese were communist, and that some how justifies our killing them; then let me ask: How many children do you know who are communists??? How many uneducated people do you know who are communists???
Communism is a form of economy and a form of relationship; but Ho Chi Minh was correct to point out that in Vietnam, the usul situation was reversed.... He was supporting a materialistic view of reality while the West, which is the most materialistic was fighting for spiritual views and values like individual freedom, and religious freedom... And as usual, we were punishing a whole people for what we considered the crimes of a few; and this is not just...